The final toleration edict of Maximin must have been issued very
soon after his defeat, and its occasion is plain enough. If he were to
oppose Licinius successfully, he must secure the loyalty of all his
subjects, and this could be done only by granting the Christians full
toleration. He could see plainly enough that Licinius’ religious
policy was a success in securing the allegiance of his subjects, and he
found himself compelled in self-defense to pursue a similar course,
distasteful as it was to him. There is no sign that he had any other
motive in taking this step. Religious considerations seem to have had
nothing to do with it; he was doubtless as much of a pagan as ever. The
edict itself is composed in an admirable vein. As Mason remarks,
“Maximin made the concession with so much dignity and grace, that
it is impossible to help wishing that his language were truer.”
As in the previous decree, he indulges his passion for lying without
restraint; but, unlike that one, the present edict is straightforward
and consistent throughout, and grants the Christians full liberty in
the most unequivocal terms.