“A most trying time has come upon us After the Council of
Diospolis Jerome suffered much from the violence of the Pelagians. See
Letters CXXXVI.–CXXXIX. in which I have found it better to hold my
peace than to speak. Consequently my studies have ceased, that I may
not give occasion to what Appius calls ‘the eloquence of
dogs.’ i.e.
railing. For this reason I have not been able
to send any answer to your two learned and brilliant letters. Not,
indeed, that I think anything in them needs correction, but that I
recall the Apostle’s words: ‘One judges in this way,
another in that; let every man give full expression to his own
opinion.’ Suo sensu abundet.
Rom. xiv. 5, Vulg. All that a lofty
intellect can draw from the well of holy scripture has been drawn by
you. So much your reverence must allow me to say in praise of your
ability. But though in any discussion between us our joint object is
the advancement of learning, our rivals and especially the heretics
will ascribe any difference of opinion between us to mutual jealousy.
For my part, however, I am resolved to love you, to look up to you, to
reverence and admire you, and to defend your opinions as my own. I have
also in a dialogue which I have recently brought out made allusion to
your holiness in suitable terms. Let us, rather, then, strain every
nerve to banish from the churches that most pernicious heresy, i.e.
Pelagianism. which feigns repentance that it may have
liberty to teach in our churches. For were it to come out into the
light of day, it would be expelled and die.”