ST. ANDREWS UNIVERSITY
the pertinacity, vigour, and consistencywithwhich he keeps before
his own mind and that of his reader certain propositions of high
generality and far-reaching significance, so as to exhibit them
from various points of view, and with most abundant, vivid,
and apt illustration. No one ever possessed in a higher degree
the power of saying virtually the same thing again and again
without rendering it stale ; and this was because, to his own
mind, it was constantly appearing in new lights, which gave it
unfailing freshness of interest. This holds more especially as
regards the systematic exposition of his philosophy in the
Institutes of Metaphysic. What Ferrier regarded as the lead-
ing merit of this work was its rigidly deductive method. He
intended it to contain and believed it to contain only propositions
either self-evident or strictly inferred from other propositions
which are self-evident. A careful examination of the book
shows that this claim is illusory. If taken seriously it exposes
Ferrier to damaging criticism, and tends to obscure the real
value of his work. Many of the pretended inferences obviously
do not mark any really fresh step at all ; they are merely restate-
ments of what has been said before, considered from a somewhat
different point of view. At certain points, there appears to be a
genuine advance and not a mere marking oftime ; but it is just at
these points that well-founded doubt arises as to the strictness of
the reasoning. The reader, when he seriously raises the question
whether the new proposition inevitably follows from the
assigned premisses, will, at first, find himself compelled to deny
that this is so ; and he will be right in this denial if the
premisses be taken in the sense in which he has been all along
understanding them. But on further reflection he will discern
that a proposition of vital importance to the argument is
ambiguous, so that if it be taken in one sense his difficulty
remains, and if it is taken in another his difficulty disappears ;
he will then, for the most part, find that it is the second
158