“This, then, is what the
man has to say who substitutes,—for we may not speak of it as
‘application,’ lest any one should blame for such madness
men holy and chosen for the preaching of godliness, so as to reproach
their doctrine with a fall into such extravagance,—who
substitutes his own mind Reading ἑαυτοῦ for the ἑαυτῶν of
Oehler’s text, for which no authority is alleged by the editor,
and which is probably a mere misprint. for the intention of
the Apostles! With what confusion are they not filled, who refer their
own nonsense to the memory of the saints! With what absurdity do they
not abound, who imagine that the man ‘emptied himself’ to
become man, and who maintain that He Who by obedience ‘humbled
himself’ to take the form of a servant was made conformable to
men even before He took that form upon Him! Who, pray, ye most reckless
of men, when he has the form of a servant, takes the form of a
servant? and how can any one ‘empty himself’ to become the
very thing which he is? You will find no contrivance to meet this, bold
as you are in saying or thinking things uncontrivable. Are you not
verily of all men most miserable, who suppose that a man has suffered
death for all men, and ascribe your own redemption to him? For if it is
not of the Word Who was in the beginning and was God that the blessed
Peter speaks, but of him who was ‘seen,’ and who
‘emptied Himself,’ as Basil says, and if the man who was
seen ‘emptied Himself’ to take ‘the form of a
servant,’ and He Who ‘emptied Himself’ to take
‘the form of a servant,’ emptied Himself to come into being
as man, then the man who was seen emptied himself to come into being as
man The
argument here takes the form of a reductio ad absurdum; assuming
that S. Peter’s reference is to the “visible man,”
and bearing in mind S. Basil’s words that S. Peter refers to Him
Who “emptied Himself,” it is said “then it was the
‘visible man’ who ‘emptied himself.’ But the
purpose of that ‘emptying’ was the ‘taking the form
of a servant,’ which again is the coming into being as man:
therefore the ‘visible man’ ‘emptied himself,’
to come into being as man, which is absurd.” The wording of S.
Basil’s statement makes the argument in a certain degree
plausible;—if he had said that S. Peter referred to the Son, not
in regard to his actual essence, but in regard to the fact that He
“emptied Himself” to become man, and as so having
“emptied Himself” (which is no doubt what he intended his
words to mean), then the reductio ad absurdum would not apply;
nor would the later arguments, by which Eunomius proceeds to prove that
He Who “emptied Himself” was no mere man, but the Word Who
was in the beginning, have any force as against S. Basil’s
statement.. The very nature of things is repugnant to
this; and it is expressly contradicted by that writer S. John i. 1 sqq.
who celebrates this dispensation in his discourse concerning the Divine
Nature, when he says not that the man who was seen, but that the Word
Who was in the beginning and was God took upon Him flesh, which is
equivalent in other words to taking ‘the form of a
servant.’ If, then, you hold that these things are to be
believed, depart from your error, and cease to believe that the man
‘emptied himself’ to become man. And if you are not able to
persuade those who will not be persuaded, destroy their incredulity by
another saying, a second decision against them. Remember
him who says, ‘Who being in the form of God thought it not
robbery to be equal with God, but emptied Himself, taking the form of a
servant.’ There is none among men who will appropriate this
phrase to himself. None of the saints that ever lived was the
Only-begotten God and became man:—for that is what it means to
‘take the form of a servant,’ ‘being in the form of
God.’ If, then, the blessed Peter speaks of Him Who
‘emptied Himself’ to ‘take the form of a
servant,’ and if He Who was ‘in the form of God’ did
‘empty Himself’ to ‘take the form of a
servant,’ and if He Who in the beginning was God, being the Word
and the Only-begotten God, is He Who was ‘in the form of
God,’ then the blessed Peter speaks to us of Him Who was in the
beginning and was God, and expounds to us that it was He Who became
Lord and Christ. This, then, is the conflict which Basil wages against
himself, and he clearly appears neither to have ‘applied his own
mind to the intention of the Apostles’, nor to be able to
preserve the sequence of his own arguments; for, according to them, he
must, if he is conscious of their irreconcilable character, admit that
the Word Who was in the beginning and was God became Lord; or if he
tries to fit together statements that are mutually conflicting, and
contentiously stands by them, he will add to them others yet more
hostile, and maintain that there are two Christs and two Lords. For if
the Word that was in the beginning and was God be one, and He Who
‘emptied Himself’ and ‘took the form of a
servant’ be another, and if God the Word, by Whom are all things,
be Lord, and this Jesus, Who was crucified after all things had come
into being, be Lord also, there are, according to his view, two Lords
and Christs. Our author, then, cannot by any argument clear himself
from this manifest blasphemy. But if any one were to say in support of
him that the Word Who was in the beginning is indeed the same Who
became Lord, but that He became Lord and Christ in respect of His
presence in the flesh, He will surely be constrained to say that the
Son was not Lord before His presence in the flesh. At all events, even
if Basil and his faithless followers falsely proclaim two Lords and two
Christs, for us there is one Lord and Christ, by Whom all things were
made, not becoming Lord by way of promotion, but existing before all
creation and before all ages, the Lord Jesus, by Whom are all things,
while all the saints with one harmonious voice teach us this truth and
proclaim it as the most excellent of doctrines. Here the blessed John
teaches us that God the Word, by Whom all things were made, has become
incarnate, saying, ‘And the Word was made flesh S. John i. 14’; here the most admirable Paul, urging
those who attend to him to humility, speaks of Christ Jesus, Who was in
the form of God, and emptied Himself to take the form of a servant, and
was humbled to death, even the death of the Cross Cf. Phil. ii. 7, 8.;
and again in another passage calls Him Who was crucified ‘the
Lord of Glory’: ‘for had they known it,’ he says,
‘they would not have crucified the Lord of Glory 1 Cor. ii. 8.’. Indeed, he speaks far more openly
than this of the very essential nature by the name of
‘Lord,’ where he says, ‘Now the Lord is the Spirit 2 Cor. iii.
17.’. If, then, the Word Who was in the
beginning, in that He is Spirit, is Lord, and the Lord of glory, and if
God made Him Lord and Christ, it was the very Spirit and God the Word
that God so made, and not some other Lord Whom Basil dreams
about.”