Himself is “in the beginning,” and is “with God,” being God, and Word, and Life, and Light,
137
and express Image, and Brightness, and if none of the things that were made throughout
creation is named by the same names—(not Word, not God, not Life, not Light, not Truth,
not express Image, not Brightness, not any of the other names proper to the Deity is to be
found employed of the creation)—then it is clear that He Who is these things is by nature
something else besides the creation, which neither is nor is called any of these things. If,
indeed, there existed in such phrases an identity of names between the creation and its
Maker, he might perhaps be excused for making the name of “creation” also common to
the thing created and to Him Who made it, on the ground of the community of the other
names: but if the characteristics which are contemplated by means of the names, in the
created and in the uncreated nature, are in no case reconcilable or common to both, how
can the misrepresentation of that man fail to be manifest to all, who dares to apply the name
of servitude to Him Who, as the Psalmist declares, “ruleth with His power for ever529,” and
to bring Him Who, as the Apostle says, “in all things hath the pre-eminence530,” to a level
with the servile nature, by means of the name and conception of “creation”? For that all531
the creation is in bondage the great Paul declares532,— he who in the schools above the
heavens was instructed in that knowledge which may not be spoken, learning these things
in that place where every voice that conveys meaning by verbal utterance is still, and where
unspoken meditation becomes the word of instruction, teaching to the purified heart by
means of the silent illumination of the thoughts those truths which transcend speech. If
then on the one hand Paul proclaims aloud “the creation is in bondage,” and on the other
the Only-begotten God is truly Lord and God over all, and John bears witness to the fact
that the whole creation of the things that were made is by Him, how can any one, who is in
any sense whatever numbered among Christians, hold his peace when he sees Eunomius,
by his inconsistent and inconsequent systematizing, degrading to the humble state of the
creature, by means of an identity of name that tends to servitude, that power of Lordship
which surpasses all rule and all authority? And if he says that he has some of the saints who
declared Him to be a slave, or created, or made, or any of these lowly and servile names, lo,
here are the Scriptures. Let him, or some other on his behalf, produce to us one such phrase,
and we will hold our peace. But if there is no such phrase (and there could never be found
in those inspired Scriptures which we believe any such thought as to support this impiety),
what need is there to strive further upon points admitted with one who not only misrepres-
ents the words of the saints, but even contends against his own definitions? For if the “order
529 Ps. lxvi. 6 (LXX.).
530 Col. i. 18.
531 Substituting πᾶσαν for the πᾶσιν of Oehler’s text.
532 Rom. viii. 21.
263
This third book shows a third fall of Eunomius, as refuting himself, and…