This text is undoubtedly false, for (a) the baptism of
the Gnostics was, according to the recognized ecclesiastical principle,
invalid, and a Gnostic coming into the Church was required to be
baptized anew; (b) besides, it would have us first to require of a
Gnostic an anathema on Nestorius, Eutyches, etc. More accurate,
therefore, is the text, as it is given by Beveridge, and as Balsamon
had it, to the effect that: “In the same way (as the
preceding) are the Manichæans, Valentinians, Marcionites, and
similar heretics to be treated (i.e., to be baptized anew); but the
Nestorians must (merely) present certificates, and anathematize their
heresy, Nestorius, Eutyches, etc.” Here we have only this
mistake, that the Nestorians must
anathematize, among others, also Eutyches, which they would certainly
have done very willingly. At the best, we must suppose that there
is a gap in the text, and that after, “all of similar
heresies,” we must add “the later heretics must present
certificates and anathematize Nestorius, Eutyches, etc.”