In accordance with the great and
orthodox synod we confess that the Son is of one substance with the
Father. And we do not so understand the term ‘of one
substance’ as some formerly interpreted it who signed their names
with feigned adhesion; nor as some who now-a-days call the drafters of
the old creed Fathers, but make the meaning of the word of no effect,
following the authors of the statement that “of one
substance” means “like,” with the understanding that
since the Son is comparable to no one of the creatures made by Him, He
is like to the Father alone. For those who thus think irreverently
define the Son “as a special creation of the Father,” but
we, with the present synods, both at Rome and in Gaul, hold that there
is one and the same substance of Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, in three
persons, that is in three perfect essences. Here for the first time in our author we meet with the word
Hypostasis to denote each distinct person. Compare note on page 36.
“Origen had already described Father, Son and Holy Spirit as
three ὑποστάσεις
or Beings, in opposition to the Monarchians, who saw
in them only three modes of manifestation of one and the same Being.
And as Sabellius had used the words τρία
πρόσωπα for
these modes of manifestation, this form of expression naturally fell
into disfavour with the Catholics. But when Arius insisted on
(virtually) three different hypostases in the Holy Trinity, Catholics
began to avoid applying the word hypostases to the Persons of the
Godhead. To this was added a difficulty arising from the fact, that the
Eastern Church used Greek as the official language of its theology,
while the Western Church used Latin, a language at that time much less
well provided with abstract theological terms. Disputes were caused,
says Gregory of Nazianzus (Orat. xxi. p. 395), διὰ
στενότητα
τῆς παρὰ τοῖς
᾽Ιτάλοις
γλώττης καὶ
ὀνομάτων
πενίαν. (Compare
Seneca Epist. 58.) The Latins used essentia and substantia as
equivalent to the Greek οὐσία and ὑπόστασις, but interchanged them, as we have seen in the translation
of the Nicene Creed with little scruple, regarding them as synonyms.
They used both expressions to describe the Divine Nature common to the
Three. It followed that they looked upon the expression “Three
Hypostases” as implying a division of the substance of the Deity,
and therefore as Arian. They preferred to speak of “tres
Personæ.” Athanasius also spoke of τρία
πρόσωπα,
and thus the words πρόσωπα and Personæ became current among the Nicene party. But about
the year 360, the Neo-Nicene party, or Meletians, as they are sometimes
called, became scrupulous about the use of such an expression as
τρία
πρόσωπα,
which seemed to them to savour of Sabellianism. Thus a difference arose
between the old Athanasian party and the Meletians.” Archd.
Cheetham in Dict. Christ. Biog. Art. “Trinity.”
And we confess, according to the exposition of Nicæa, that the Son
of God being of one substance, was made flesh of the Holy Virgin Mary,
and hath tabernacled among men, and fulfilled all the economy Compare note on page 72. for our sakes in birth, in passion, in
resurrection, and in ascension into Heaven; and that He shall come
again to render to us according to each man’s manner of life, in
the day of judgment, being seen in the flesh, and showing forth His
divine power, being God bearing flesh, and not man bearing
Godhead.