The translation which follows has been carefully
compared with one made by the late Prof. Swainson in his work on the
Creeds, pp. 73–76. Dr. Swainson there refers to a former
‘imperfect and misleading’ translation (in Irons’
Athanasius contra Mundum) which the present editor has not seen.
Dr. Swainson expresses doubts as to the Athanasian authorship of the
Ecthesis, but without any cogent reason. The only point of importance
is one which acquaintance with the usual language of Athanasius shews
to make distinctly in favour of, and not against, the genuineness of
this little tract. Three times in the course of it the Human Body, or
Humanity of the Lord is spoken of as ὁ
Κυριακός
ἄνθρωπυς. Dr. Swainson
exaggerates the strangeness of the expression by the barbarous
rendering ‘Lordly man’ (How would he translate κυριακὸν
δεῖπνον?). But the phrase
certainly requires explanation, although the explanation is not
difficult. (1) It is quoted by Facundus of Hermiane from the present
work (Def. Tr. Cap. xi. 5), and by Rufinus from an unnamed work
of Athanasius (‘libellus’), probably the present one.
Moreover, Athanasius himself uses the phrase, frequently in the
Sermo Major de Fide, and in his exposition of Psalm xl. (xli.).
Epiphanius uses it at least twice (Ancor. 78 and 95); and from
these Greek Fathers the phrase (‘Dominicus Homo’) passed on
to Latin writers such as Cassian and Augustine (below, note 5), who,
however, subsequently cancelled his adoption of the expression
(Retr. I. xix. 8). The phrase, therefore, is not to be objected
to as un-Athanasian. In fact (2) it is founded upon the profuse and
characteristic use by Ath. of the word ἄνθρωπος to designate the
manhood of our Lord (see Orat. c. Ar. i. 41, 45, ii. 45, note 2.
Dr. Swainson appears unaware of this in his unsatisfactory paragraph p.
77, lines 14 and foll.). If the human nature of Christ may be called
ἄνθρωπος (1 Tim. ii. 5) at all, there is no difficulty in its
being called ὁ ἄνθρ. τοῦ
σωτῆρος (Serm. M. de
F. 24 and 30), or κυριακὸς
ἄνθρωπος, a phrase
equated with τὸ [κυριακὸν] σῶμα in
Serm. M. de F. 19 and 28–31 (see also a discussion in
Thilo Athan. Opp. Dogm. select. p. 2). This use of the word
ἄνθρωπος, if carelessly
employed, might lend itself to a Nestorian sense. But Athanasius does
not employ it carelessly, nor in an ambiguous context; although of
course he might have used different language had he foreseen the
controversies of the fifth century. At any rate, enough has been said
to shew that its use in the present treatise does not expose its
genuineness to cavil.