(iii.) The Commentary on
Isaiah. The Commentary on Isaiah is placed by the Benedictine
Editors in the appendix of doubtful composition, mainly on the ground
of inferiority of style. Ceillier is strongly in favour of the
genuineness of this work, and calls attention to the fact that it is
attested by strong manuscript authority, and by the recognition of St.
Maximus, of John of Damascus, of Simeon Logothetes, of Antony Melissa
of Tarasius, and of the Greek scholiast on the Epistles of St. Paul,
who is supposed to be Œcumenius. Fessler Patr. i.
522.
ranks the work among those of doubtful authority on the ground of the
silence of earlier Fathers and of the inferiority of style, as well as
of apparent citations from the Commentary of Eusebius, and of some
eccentricity of opinion. He conjectures that we may possibly have
here the rough material of a proposed work on Isaiah, based mainly on
Origen, which was never completed. Garnier regards it as totally
unworthy of St. Basil. Maran ( Vit. Bas. 42) would accept
it, and refutes objections.