subsisting with the Father. For neither is the figure of breath intended to convey to us the
notion of dispersion into the air from the material from which it is formed, nor is the figure
of fragrance designed to express the passing off of the quality of the ointment into the air,
nor the figure of effulgence the efflux which takes place by means of the rays from the body
of the sun: but as has been said in all cases, by such a mode of generation is indicated this
alone, that the Son is of the Father and is conceived of along with Him, no interval intervening
between the Father and Him Who is of the Father. For since of His exceeding loving-kindness
the grace of the Holy Spirit so ordered that the divine conceptions concerning the Only-
begotten should reach us from many quarters, and so be implanted in us, He added also the
remaining kind of generation,—that, namely, of the word from the mind. And here the
sublime John uses remarkable foresight. That the reader might not through inattention and
unworthy conceptions sink to the common notion of “word,” so as to deem the Son to be
merely a voice of the Father, he therefore affirms of the Word that He essentially subsisted
in the first and blessed nature Itself, thus proclaiming aloud, “In the Beginning was the
Word, and with God, and God, and Light, and Life355,” and all that the Beginning is, the
Word was also.
Since, then, these kinds of generation, those, I mean, which arise as the result of some
cause, and are recognized in our every-day experience, are also employed by Holy Scripture
to convey its teaching concerning transcendent mysteries in such wise as each of them may
reasonably be transferred to the expression of divine conceptions, we may now proceed to
examine Eunomius’ statement also, to find in what sense he accepts the meaning of “gener-
ation.” “Very Son,” he says, “not ungenerate, verily begotten before the worlds.” One may,
I think, pass quickly over the violence done to logical sequence in his distinction, as being
easily recognizable by all. For who does not know that while the proper opposition is between
Father and Son, between generate and ungenerate, he thus passes over the term “Father”
and sets “ungenerate” in opposition to “Son,” whereas he ought, if he had any concern for
truth, to have avoided diverting his phrase from the due sequence of relationship, and to
have said, “Very Son, not Father”? And in this way due regard would have been paid at once
to piety and to logical consistency, as the nature would not have been rent asunder in making
the distinction between the persons. But he has exchanged in his statement of his faith the
true and scriptural use of the term “Father,” committed to us by the Word Himself, and
speaks of the “Ungenerate” instead of the “Father,” in order that by separating Him from
that close relationship towards the Son which is naturally conceived of in the title of Father,
he may place Him on a common level with all created objects, which equally stand in oppos-
355 Cf. S. John i. 1 sqq.
220
Gregory again discusses the generation of the Only-Begotten, and other different…