33. These are the evil sophistries of the
heterodox; yet, though we have already shewn their shallowness, the
exact sense of these passages themselves and the force of these
illustrations will serve to shew the baseless nature of their loathsome
tenet. For we see that reason is ever, and is from him and proper to
his essence, whose reason it is, and does not admit a before and an
after. So again we see that the radiance from the sun is proper to it,
and the sun’s essence is not divided or impaired; but its essence
is whole and its radiance perfect and whole The
Second Person in the Holy Trinity is not a quality of attribute or
relation, but the One Eternal Substance; not a part of the First
Person, but whole or entire God; nor does the generation impair the
Father’s Substance, which is, antecedently to it, whole and
entire God. Thus there are two Persons, in Each Other ineffably, Each
being wholly one and the same Divine Substance, yet not being merely
separate aspects of the Same, Each being God as absolutely as if there
were no other Divine Person but Himself. Such a statement indeed is not
only a contradiction in the terms used, but in our ideas, yet not
therefore a contradiction in fact; unless indeed any one will say that
human words can express in one formula, or human thought embrace in one
idea, the unknown and infinite God. Basil. contr. Eun. i. 10.
vid. infr. §38, n. 3.,
yet without impairing the essence of light, but as a true offspring
from it. We understand in like manner that the Son is begotten not from
without but from the Father, and while the Father remains whole, the
Expression of His Subsistence is ever, and preserves the Father’s
likeness and unvarying Image, so that he who sees Him, sees in Him the
Subsistence too, of which He is the Expression. And from the operation
of the Expression we understand the true Godhead of the Subsistence, as
the Saviour Himself teaches when He says, ‘The Father who
dwelleth in Me, He doeth the works John xiv. 10.’ which I
do; and ‘I and the Father are one,’ and ‘I in the
Father and the Father in Me John x. 30..’ Therefore
let this Christ—opposing heresy attempt first to divide διελεῖν, vid. §25, note 3. the examples found in things originate, and
say, ‘Once the sun was without his radiance,’ or,
‘Radiance is not proper to the essence of light,’ or
‘It is indeed proper, but it is a part of light by division; and
then let it divide Reason, and pronounce that it is foreign to mind, or
that once it was not, or that it was not proper to its essence, or that
it is by division a part of mind.’ And so of His Expression and
the Light and the Power, let it do violence to these as in the case of
Reason and Radiance; and instead let it imagine what it will Hist. Ar. 52, n. 4.. But if such extravagance be impossible for
them, are they not greatly beside themselves, presumptuously intruding
into what is higher than things originate and their own nature, and
essaying impossibilities In
illud. Omn. 6. init.?