The incorporation in this volume of so much of
the ample patristic learning of Cardinal Newman has inevitably involved
some sacrifice of uniformity. To provide the new matter with
illustrative notes on anything like the same scale, even had it been
within the present editor’s power, would have involved the
crowding out of many works which the reader will certainly prefer to
have before him. Again, many opinions are expressed by Cardinal Newman
which the present editor is unable to accept. It may not be invidious
to specify as an example the many cases in which the notes enforce
views of Church authority, especially of papal authority, or again of
the justifiableness of religious persecution, which appear to be at any
rate foreign to the mind of Athanasius; or the tacit assumption that
the men of the fourth century can be divided by a broad and fast line
into orthodox and heretical, and that while everything may be believed
to the discredit of the latter, the former were at once uniform in
their convictions and consistently right in practice. Such an
assumption operates with special injustice against men like Eusebius,
whose position does not fall in with so summary a classification. But
it has been thought better to leave the notes in nearly all such cases
as they stand, only very rarely inserting a reference or observation to
call attention to another aspect of the case. And in no instance has
the editor forgotten the respect due to the theological learning and
personal greatness of Cardinal Newman, or to his peculiar eminence as a
religious thinker.