Usia (οὐσία) is defined by Cyril of
Alexandria as that which has existence in itself, independent of
everything else to constitute it. A discussion of both it and its
companion term hypostasis may be found in Newman’s Arians,
Appendix p. 432. Around οὐσία, or some compound of the
word, the great Arian controversy always raged. In asserting that the
son was homoousios with the Father, i.e., consubstantial or
co-essential, the Church affirmed the Godhead of the Son. But the
formula experienced varying fortunes. It was disowned as savouring of
heterodoxy by the Council of Antioch (264–269) which was held to
decide upon the views of Paulus: was imposed at Nicæa (325):
considered inexpedient by the great body of the episcopate in the next
generation: was most cautiously put forward by Athanasius himself (see
Stanley’s Hist. of Eastern Church, 1883, p. 240): does not occur
in the catecheses of S. Cyril of Jerusalem (347): was momentarily
abandoned by 400 bishops at Ariminum who were “tricked and
worried” into the act. “They had not,” says Newman,
“yet got it deeply fixed in their minds as a sort of first
principle, that to abandon the formula was to betray the
faith.”