things according to our nature, and measures the eternal by a past and a future, where
neither the past precludes the march of thought to the illimitable and infinite, nor the future
tells us of any pause or limit of His endless life. If, then, it is thus that we think and speak,
why does he keep taunting us with dividing the ages? Unless, indeed, Eunomius would
maintain that Holy Scripture does so too, signifying as it does by the same idea the infinity
of the Divine existence; David, for example, making mention of the “kingdom from everlast-
ing,” and Moses, speaking of the kingdom of God as “extending beyond all ages,” so that
we are taught by both that every duration conceivable is environed by the Divine nature,
bounded on all sides by the infinity of Him Who holds the universe in His embrace. For
Moses, looking to the future, says that “He reigneth from generation to generation for
evermore.” And great David, turning his thought backward to the past, says, “God is our
King before the ages1187,” and again, “God, Who was before the ages, shall hear us.” But
Eunomius, in his cleverness taking leave of such guides as these, says that we talk of the life
that is without beginning as one, and of that which is without end as quite another, and
again, of diversities of sundry ages, effecting by their own diversity a separation in our idea
of God. But that our controversy may not grow to a tedious length, we will add, without
criticism or comment, the outcome of Eunomius’ labours on the subject, well fitted as they
are by his industry displayed in the cause of error to render the truth yet more evident to
the eyes of the discerning.
For, proceeding with his discourse, he asks us what we mean by the ages. And yet we
ourselves might more reasonably put such questions to him. For it is he who professes to
know the essence of God, defining on his own authority what is unapproachable and incom-
prehensible by man. Let him, then, give us a scientific lecture on the nature of the ages,
297
boasting as he does of his familiarity with transcendental things, and let him not so fiercely
brandish over us, poor ignorant individuals, the double danger of the dilemma involved in
our reply, telling us that, whether we hold this or that view of the ages, the result must be
in either case an absurdity. For if (says he) you say that they are eternal, you will be Greeks,
and Valentinians1188, and uninstructed1189: and if you say that they are generate, you will
no longer be able to ascribe ungeneracy to God. What a terribly unanswerable attack! If, O
1187 Cf. Ps. xliv. 4, and xlviii. 14, with lxxiv. 12.
1188 Valentinus “placed in the pleroma (so the Gnostics called the habitation of the Deity) thirty æons (ages),
of which one half were male, and the other female” (Mosheim), i.e. these æons were co-eternal with the Deity.
1189 βάρβαροι here being not opposed to “Greeks” must imply mere inability to speak aright: amongst those
who claimed to use Catholic language another “barbarism,” or “jargon,” had arisen (i.e. that of heresy, whether
Platonist or Gnostic), different from that which separated the Greeks from the Jews, Africans, Romans alike.
Hesychius; βάρβαροι οἱ ἀπαίδευτοι. So to S. Paul “the people” of Malta (Acts xxviii. 2–4), as to others the Apostles,
were barbarian.
557
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.