§4.
Eusebius’ Accession to the Bishopric of
Cæsarea.
Not long after the close of the
persecution, Eusebius became bishop of Cæsarea in Palestine, his
own home, and held the position until his death. The exact date of his
accession cannot be ascertained, indeed we cannot say that it did not
take place even before the close of the persecution, but that is hardly
probable; in fact, we know of no historian who places it earlier than
313. His immediate predecessor in the episcopate was Agapius, whom he
mentions in terms of praise in
H. E.
VII. 32. Some writers have
interpolated a bishop Agricolaus between Agapius and Eusebius (see
e.g.
Tillemont,
Hist. Eccles.
VII. 42), on the ground
that his name appears in one of the lists of those present at the
Council of Ancyra (c. 314), as bishop of Cæsarea in Palestine (see
Labbei et Cossartii Conc.
I. 1475). But, as Hefele shows
(
Conciliengesch.
I. 220), this list is of late date and not to
be relied upon. On the other hand, as Lightfoot points out, in the
Libellus Synodicus
(
Conc
. I. 1480), where Agricolaus is
said to have been present at the Council of Ancyra, he is called bishop
of Cæsarea in Cappadocia; and this statement is confirmed by a
Syriac list given in Cowper’s
Miscellanies,
p. 41. Though
perhaps no great reliance is to be
placed upon the correctness of
any of these lists, the last two may at any rate be set over against
the first, and we may conclude that there exists no ground for assuming
that Agapius, who is the last Cæsarean bishop mentioned by
Eusebius, was not the latter’s immediate predecessor. At what
time Agapius died we do not know. That he suffered martyrdom is hardly
likely, in view of Eusebius’ silence on the subject. It would
seem more likely that he outlived the persecution. However that may be,
Eusebius was already bishop at the time of the dedication of a new and
elegant Church at Tyre under the direction of his friend Paulinus,
bishop of that city. Upon this occasion he delivered an address of
considerable length, which he has inserted in his
Ecclesiastical
History,
Bk. X. chap. 4. He does not name himself as its author,
but the way in which he introduces it, and the very fact that he
records the whole speech without giving the name of the man who
delivered it, make its origin perfectly plain. Moreover, the last
sentence of the preceding chapter makes it evident that the speaker was
a bishop: “Every one of the rulers (
ἀρχόντων
) present delivered panegyric discourses.” The date of the
dedication of this church is a matter of dispute, though it is commonly
put in the year 315. It is plain from Eusebius’ speech that it
was uttered before Licinius had begun to persecute the Christians, and
also, as Görres remarks, at a time when Constantine and Licinius
were at least outwardly at peace with each other. In the year 314 the
two emperors went to war, and consequently, if the persecution of
Licinius began soon after that event, as it is commonly supposed to
have done, the address must have been delivered before hostilities
opened; that is, at least as early as 314, and this is the year in
which Görres places it (
Kritische Untersuchungen ueber die
licinianische Christenverfolgung
, p. 8). But if Görres’
date (319
a.d.
) for the commencement of the
persecution be accepted (and though he can hardly be said to have
proved it, he has urged some strong grounds in support of it), then the
address may have been delivered at almost any time between 315 and 319,
for, as Görres himself shows, Licinius and Constantine were
outwardly at peace during the greater part of that time (
ib
. p.
14, sq.). There is nothing in the speech itself which prevents this
later date, nor is it intrinsically improbable that the great basilica
reached completion only in 315 or later. In fact, it must be admitted
that Eusebius may have become bishop at any time between about 311 and
318.
The persecution of Licinius,
which continued until his defeat by Constantine, in 323, was but local,
and seems never to have been very severe. Indeed, it did not bear the
character of a bloody persecution, though a few bishops appear to have
met their death on one ground or another. Palestine and Egypt seem not
to have suffered to any great extent (see Görres,
ib
. p. 32
sq.).