The addition of the phrase condemned by this canon was
probably made first by Peter Fullo, and although indeed it was capable
of a good meaning, if the whole hymn was understood as being addressed
to Christ, and although this was admitted by very many of the orthodox,
yet as it was chiefly used by the Monophysites and with an undoubtedly
heretical intention, it was finally ousted from this position and its adherents were styled
Theopaschites. From all this it came about that by 518 it was a
source of disagreement among the Catholics, some affirming the
expression, as looked at by itself, to be a touchstone of
orthodoxy. The Emperor Justinian tried to have it approved by
Pope Hormisdas, but unsuccessfully, the pontiff only declaring that it
was unnecessary, and even dangerous. Fulgentius of Ruspe and
Dionysius Exiguus had declared it orthodox. Pope John II. almost
came to the point of approving the phrase “one of the Trinity
suffered,” nor did his successor Agapetus I. speak any more
definitely on the point, but the Fifth Ecumenical Council directly
approved the formula.