If the reader will be at the pains to look on the discourse
whence these passages are taken, I shall desire no more of his favour but
that he profess himself to be a Christian, and then let him freely
pronounce whether he find any thing in it obnoxious to censure. Or, I
desire that any man, who hath not forfeited all reason and ingenuity unto
faction and party, if he differ from me, truly to state wherein, and oppose
what I have said with an answer unto the testimonies wherewith it is
confirmed, referred unto in the margin of my discourse. But the way of
this author’s proceeding, if there be no plea to be made for it from his
ignorance and unacquaintedness not only with the person of Christ, but with
most of the other things he undertakes to write about, is altogether
inexcusable. The way whereby I have expressed the consent of the soul in
the receiving of Jesus Christ, to be justified, sanctified, saved by him, I
still avow, as suited unto the mind of the Holy Ghost, and the experience
of them that really believe. And whereas I added, that before believing,
the soul did seek for salvation by the works of the law, as it is natural
unto all, and as the Holy Ghost affirms of some (whose words alone I used,
and expressly quoted that place from whence I took them, — namely,
Rom. ix. 31, 32;) — this man adds, as
an exposition of that expression, “That is, by obeying the laws of the
gospel.” But he knew that these were the words of the apostle, or he did
not; if he did not, nor would take notice of them so to be,
although directed to the place from whence they are taken, it is evident
how meet he is to debate matters of this nature and concernment, and how
far he is yet from being in danger to “pore out his eyes” in reading the
Scripture, as he pretends. If he did know them to be his words, why doth
he put such a sense upon them as, in his own apprehension, is derogatory to
gospel obedience? Whatever he thought of beforehand, it is likely he will
now say that it is my sense, and not the apostle’s, which he intends. But
how will he prove that I intended any other sense than that of the apostle?
how should this appear? Let him, if he can, produce any word in my whole
discourse intimating any other sense. Nay, it is evident that I had no
other intention but only to refer unto that place of the apostle, and the
proper sense of it; which is to express the mind and actings of those who,
being ignorant of the righteousness of God, go about to establish their own
righteousness; as he farther explains himself, Rom.
x. 3, 4. That I could not intend obedience unto the laws of the
gospel is so evident, that nothing but abominable prejudice or ignorance
could hinder any man from discerning it. For that faith which I expressed
by the soul’s consent to take Christ as a saviour and a ruler, is the very
first act of obedience unto the gospel: so that therein or thereon to
exclude obedience unto the gospel, is to deny what I assert; which, under
the favour of this author, I understand myself better than to do. And as
to all other acts of obedience unto the laws of the gospel, following and
proceeding from sincere believing, it is openly evident that I could not
understand them when I spake only of what was antecedent unto them. And if
this man knows not what transactions are in the minds of many before they
do come unto the acceptance of Christ on his own terms, or believe in him
according to the tenor of the gospel, there is reason to pity the people
that are committed unto his care and instruction, what regard soever ought
to be had unto himself. And his pitiful trifling in the exposition he adds
of this passage, “To be saved without doing any thing, without obeying
thee, and the law,” doth but increase the guilt of his prevarications; for
the words immediately added in my discourse are, — “And although I have
walked according unto mine own mind, yet now I wholly give up myself to be
ruled by thy Spirit;” which, unto the understanding of all men who
understand any thing in these matters, signify no less than an engagement
unto the universal relinquishment of sin, and entire obedience unto Jesus
Christ in all things. “But this,” saith he, “is a pretty compliment that
the soul makes to Christ after all.” But why is this to be esteemed only a
“pretty compliment?” It is spoken at the same time, and, as it were, with
the same breath, there being in the discourse no period between this
passage and that before; and why must it be esteemed quite of
another nature, so that herein the soul should only compliment, and be real
in what is before expressed? What if one should say, it was real only in
this latter expression and engagement, that the former was only a “pretty
compliment?” May it not, with respect unto my sense and intention (from
any thing in my words, or that can be gathered from them, or any
circumstances of the place), be spoken with as much regard unto truth and
honesty? What religion these men are of I know not. If it be such as
teacheth them these practices, and countenanceth them in them, I openly
declare that I am not of it, nor would be so for all that this world can
afford. I shall have done, when I have desired him to take notice, that I
not only believe and maintain the necessity of obedience unto all the laws,
precepts, commands, and institutions of the gospel, — of universal
holiness, the mortification of all sin, fruitfulness in good works, in all
that intend or design salvation by Jesus Christ; but also have proved and
confirmed my persuasion and assertions by better and more cogent arguments
than any which, by his writings, he seems as yet to be acquainted withal.
And unless he can prove that I have spoken or written any thing to the
contrary, or he can disprove the arguments whereby I have confirmed it, I
do here declare him a person altogether unfit to be dealt withal about
things of this nature, his ignorance or malice being invincible; nor shall
I, on any provocation, ever hereafter take notice of him until he hath
mended his manners.