Two
distinct meanings may be attached to ‘by will’ (as Dr.
Clark observes, Script. Doct. p. 142. ed. 1738), either a
concurrence or acquiescence, or a positive act. S. Cyril uses it in the
former sense, when he calls it σύνδρομος, as quoted §60, n. 1; and when he says (with Athan.
infr.) that ‘the Father wills His own subsistence,
θεληγής
ἐστι, but is not what He
is from any will, ἐκ
βουλήσεως
τινός,’
Thes. p. 56; Dr. Clark would understand it in the latter sense,
with a view of inferring that the Son was subsequent to a Divine act,
i.e. not eternal; but what Athan. says leads to the conclusion, that it
does not matter which sense is taken. He does not meet the Arian
objection, ‘if not by will therefore by necessity,’ by
speaking of a concomitant will, or merely saying that the Almighty
exists or is good, by will, with S. Cyril, but he says that
‘nature transcends will and necessity also.’
Accordingly, Petavius is even willing to allow that the ἐκ
βουλῆς is to be
ascribed to the γέννησις in the sense which Dr. Clark wishes, i.e. he grants that it
may precede the γέννησις, i.e. in order, not in time, in the succession of
our ideas, Trin. vi. 8, §§20, 21; and follows S.
Austin, Trin. xv. 20. in preferring to speak of our Lord rather
as voluntas de voluntate, than, as Athan. is led to do, as the voluntas
Dei.