an accountable being, who at the same time can be accountable for nothing; and it would be to impute blame
to principles, or a principle, which is incapable of moral agencies. 6. The cause of virtuous acts, or, if we may so
speak, the soil in which they grow, is a previous inclination or disposition to good, before any actual choice takes
place. This may be called a virtuous inclination, or disposition. But the original and predisposing cause of that,
is divine energy, influx, or influence; in other words, an assimilating emanation form the holy nature and decretive
will of God. 7. Nevertheless, this is not a good, or a virtue, attributable to man, until he is actually possessed of
it, or it becomes his, as a quality of his nature. God, the Father of lights, from whom every good and perfect gift
proceedeth, is the cause of that virtuous disposition; but while the virtue remained in the cause, and not in the
man, it was no human virtue. Nor does the essence of human virtue lie in the communication itself, for this was
the effect of divine will; but no will can alter the nature of virtue: therefore, the essence of virtue consists not in
the cause, whether we understand by “cause”, the Will that communicates the virtuous disposition, or the
communication itself. Consequently, the absence of virtue is so completely confined to the disposition of the
agent, and the consequent acts, as to exclude every thing else that may be termed its cause. 8. The cause of vicious
acts, whatever it be, is opposite to the cause of virtuous acts; for these acts have diametrically opposite effects.
That vicious acts have a cause, as well as virtuous ones, cannot be denied by any reflecting person, for this plain
reason, that there is nothing in the universality of things, beings, qualities, &c. but had a cause, either positive
or negative, as before explained. Neither agency, liberty, nor nay thing else, considered as an effect, or a con-
sequent, can exist without a cause, or antecedent. The denial of this, and universal scepticism, are the same
thing. Then all reasoning, and all common sense, vanish. Then body and spirit, cause and effects, good and evil,
&c. are huddled up in endless confusion, without either first or last, great or small, order or proportion. 9. The
original, predisposing cause of a vicious disposition, is the very opposite of the original, predisposing cause of
a virtuous disposition. This last, it has been shown, is divine energy, which is a positive cause; the other, the
opposite of this, is a negative cause. The cause of good, as before observed, is a cause properly so called, in the
way of physical influence; but the cause of evil is called “a cause” improperly, as it implies no physical influence,
but only stands as an antecedent to a consequent; from which however the consequent may be inferred with as
much certainty as if the influence were physical and mechanical. Whether you suppose positive quantities, or
negative quantities, consequences are equally certain, it is no less true that 5-2=3, than 1-33=6. Whether you
say, If the sun were not, it would cause darkness; or say, If the sun shine, it will cause light; the difference is only
in the nature of the cause, as either positive or negative, not in the certainty of the consequence. 10. It would be
very absurd and contradictory to say that the cause of vice is vicious. For that would be the same as to say, that
a thing was before it existed. To be vicious is to have vice; and for this to be the cause of vice, is for it to be the
cause of itself, or self-caused, which is absurd. It is therefore impossible that the cause of vice should be vicious;
consequently the essence of vice is no where but in its own proper nature, to the exclusion of every cause whatever.
And yet, as it is an effect, it must have a cause. 11. The principle question to be determined, in this investigation,
is, What is precisely the original, predisposing, negative cause of a vicious disposition? The answer is plain and
short; it is that property of a creature which renders it absolutely dependent for its being and well-being. Or, it
is that property which is the very opposite too independence, self-sufficiency, and immutability: and therefore
is a property peculiar to a creature, and cannot belong to God. 12. Nor can this be said to be an actually existing
property form eternity; since it cannot belong to God, and nothing, the only alternative, has no property. It is
673
SECTION I. The Essence of the virtue and vice of dispositions of the heart,…