guments on absurd opinions, and some of his own opinions strike us as childish and obsolete.
He confines the Kingdom of God to the narrow limits of the Jewish theocracy and the visible
Catholic Church. He could, indeed, not deny the truths in Greek philosophy; but he derived
them from the Jewish Scriptures, and adopted the impossible hypothesis of Ambrose that
Plato became acquainted with the prophet Jeremiah in Egypt (comp. De Doctr. Christ. II.
28), though afterwards he corrected it (Retract. II. 4). He does not sufficiently appreciate
the natural virtues, the ways of Divine providence and the working of His Spirit outside of
the chosen race; and under the influence of the ascetic spirit which then prevailed in the
Church, in justifiable opposition to the surrounding moral corruption of heathenism, he
even degrades secular history and secular life, in the state and the family, which are likewise
ordained of God. In some respects he forms the opposite extreme to Origen, the greatest
genius among the Greek fathers. Both assume a universal fall from original holiness. But
Augustin dates it from one act of disobedience,—the historic fall of Adam, in whom the
whole race was germinally included; while Origen goes back to a pre-historic fall of each
individual soul, making each responsible for the abuse of freedom. Augustin proceeds to
a special election of a people of God from the corrupt and condemned mass; he follows their
history in two antagonistic lines, and ends in the dualistic contrast of an eternal heaven for
the elect and an eternal hell for the reprobate, including among the latter even unbaptized
infants (horribile dictu!), who never committed an actual transgression; while Origen leads
all fallen creatures, men and angels, by a slow and gradual process of amendment and cor-
rection, under the ever-widening influence of redeeming mercy, during the lapse of countless
ages, back to God, some outstripping others and tending by a swifter course towards perfec-
tion, until the last enemy is finally reached and death itself is destroyed, that “God may be
all in all.” Within the limits of the Jewish theocracy and Catholic Christianity Augustin
admits the idea of historical development or a gradual progress from a lower to higher grades
of knowledge, yet always in harmony with Catholic truth. He would not allow revolutions
and radical changes or different types of Christianity. “The best thinking” (says Dr. Flint,
in his Philosophy of History in Europe, I. 40), “at once the most judicious and liberal, among
those who are called the Christian fathers, on the subject of the progress of Christianity as
an organization and system, is that of St. Augustin, as elaborated and applied by Vincent
of Lerins in his ‘Commonitorium,’ where we find substantially the same conception of the
development of the Church and Christian doctrine, which, within the present century, De
Maistre has made celebrated in France, Möhler in Germany, and Newman in England. Its
main defect is that it places in the Church an authority other than, and virtually higher than,
Scripture and reason, to determine what is true and false in the development of doctrine.”
With all its defects the candid reader will be much instructed and edified by “the City
of God,” and find more to admire than to censure in this immortal work of sanctified
genius and learning.
4
Editor’s Preface