210 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [ Boox rv.
While, therefore, you accuse, without making [any] excep-
tion, not one only by name, but the whole of the gods alike,
in whose existence you believe, of such acts of extraordinary
shamefulness and baseness, do you dare, without violation of
modesty, to say either that we are impious, or that you are
pious, although they receive from you much greater occasion
for offence on account of all the shameful acts which you
heap up to their reproach, than in connection with the
service and duties required by their majesty, honour, and
worship? For either all these things are false which you
bring forward about them individually, lessening their credit
and reputation; and it is [in that case] a matter quite de-
serving, that the gods should utterly destroy the race of men ;
or if they are true and certain, and perceived without any
reasons for doubt, it comes to this issue, that, however un-
willing you may be, we believe them to be not of heavenly,
but of earthly birth.
28. For where there are weddings, marriages, births,
nurses, arts,’ and weaknesses; where there is liberty and
slavery; where there are wounds, slaughter, and [shedding
of] blood; where there are lusts, desires, sensual pleasures ;
where there is every mental passion arising from disgusting
emotions,—there must of necessity be nothing godlike there ;
nor can that cleave to a superior nature which belongs to
a fleeting race, and to the frailty of earth. For who, if only
he recognises and perceives what the nature of that power is,
can believe either that a deity had the generative members,
and was deprived of them by a very base operation ; or that
he at one time cut off the children sprung from himself, and
was punished by suffering imprisonment; or that he, in a
way, made civil war upon his father, and deprived him of
the right of governing; or that he, filled with fear of one
younger when overcome, turned to flight, and hid in remote
solitudes, like a fugitive and exile? Who, I say, can believe
li, either the arts which belong to each god (cf. the words in
ii 18: * these [arts] are not the gifts of science, but the discoveries of
necessity”), or, referring to the words immediately preceding, obstetric
arts. .