‘What point of doctrine was wanting to the piety
of the catholic church, that they should now make an investigation
respecting the faith, and prefix moreover the consulate of the present
times to their published exposition of it? For Ursacius, Valens, and
Germinius have done what was neither done, nor even heard of, at any
time before among Christians: having composed a creed such as they
themselves are willing to believe, they prefaced it with the consulate,
month, and day of the present time, in order to prove to all discerning
persons that theirs is not the ancient faith, but such as was
originated under the reign of the present emperor Constantius.
This appeal to antiquity, as the test of truth, is
very common with the earlier Fathers; cf. Eusebius’ treatment of
the Scriptures of the New Testament, H. E. III. 3, 24, 25, et
al.
Moreover they have written all things with a view to their own heresy:
and besides this, pretending to write respecting the Lord, they name
another “Lord” as theirs, even Constantius, who has
countenanced their impiety, so that those who deny the Son to be
eternal, have styled him eternal emperor. Thus are they proved to be
the enemies of Christ by their profanity. But perhaps the holy
prophets’ record of time afforded them a precedent for [noticing]
the consulate! Now even if they should presume to make this pretext,
they would most glaringly expose their own ignorance. The prophecies of
these holy men do indeed mark the times. Isaiah and Hosea lived in the
days of Uzziah, Joatham, Ahaz, and Hezekiah;
Isa. i. 2;
Hos. i. 1.
Jeremiah in the time of Josiah;
Jer. i.
2.
Ezekiel and Daniel in the reign of Cyrus and Darius; and others uttered
their predictions in other times. Yet they did not then lay the
foundations of religion. That was in existence before them, and always
was, even before the creation of the world, God having prepared it for
us in Christ. Nor did they designate the commencement of their own
faith; for they were themselves men of faith previously: but they
signified the times of the promises given through them. Now the
promises primarily referred to our Saviour’s advent; and all that
was foretold respecting the course of future events in relation to
Israel and the Gentiles was collateral and subordinate. Hence the
periods mentioned indicated not the beginning of their faith, as I
before observed, but the times in which these prophets lived and
foretold such things. But these sages of our day, who neither compile
histories, nor predict future events, after writing, “The
Catholic Faith was published,” immediately add the consulate,
with the month and the day: and as the holy prophets wrote the date of
their records and of their own ministration, so these men intimate the
era of their own faith. And would that they had written concerning
their own faith only—since they have now begun to
believe—and had not undertaken to write respecting the Catholic
faith. For they have not written, “Thus we believe”; but,
“The Catholic Faith was
published.” The temerity of purpose herein manifested argues
their ignorance; while the novelty of expression found in the document
they have concocted shows it to be the same as the Arian heresy. By
writing in this manner, they have declared when they themselves began
to believe, and from what time they wish it to be understood their
faith was first preached. And just as when the evangelist Luke says,
Luke ii.
1.
“A decree of enrolment was published,” he speaks of an
edict which was not in existence before, but came into operation at
that time, and was published by him who had written it; so these men by
writing “The faith has now been published,” have declared
that the tenets of their heresy are of modern invention, and did not
exist previously. But since they apply the term “Catholic”
to it, they seem to have unconsciously fallen into the extravagant
assumption of the Cataphrygians, asserting even as they did, that
“the Christian faith was first revealed to us, and commenced with
us.” And as those termed Maximilla and Montanus, so these style
Constantius their Lord, instead of Christ. But if according to them the
faith had its beginning from the present consulate, what will the
fathers and the blessed martyrs do? Moreover what will they themselves
do with those who were instructed in religious principles by them, and
died before this consulate? By what means will they recall them to
life, in order to obliterate from their minds what they seemed to have
taught them, and to implant in its stead those new discoveries which
they have published? So stupid are they as to be only capable of
framing pretenses, and these such as are unbecoming and unreasonable,
and carry with them their own refutation.’