51. And again, if, as we have said before, the
Son is not such by participation, but, while all things originated have
by participation the grace of God, He is the Father’s Wisdom and
Word of which all things partake De
Decr. §10. p. 15, note 4., it follows
that He, being the deifying and enlightening power of the Father, in
which all things are deified and quickened, is not alien in essence
from the Father, but coessential. For by partaking of Him, we partake
of the Father; because that the Word is the Father’s own. Whence,
if He was Himself too from participation, and not from the Father His
essential Godhead and Image, He would not deify ἐθεοποίησε
Orat.ii. §70.
de Decr. §14.,
being deified Himself. For it is not possible that He, who merely
possesses from participation, should impart of that partaking to
others, since what He has is not His own, but the Giver’s; and
what He has received, is barely the grace sufficient for Himself.
However, let us fairly examine the reason why some, as is said, decline
the ‘Coessential,’ whether it does not rather shew that the
Son is coessential with the Father. They say then, as you have written,
that it is not right to say that the Son is coessential with the
Father, because he who speaks of ‘coessential’ speaks of
three, one essence pre-existing, and that those who are generated from
it are coessential: and they add, ‘If then the Son be coessential
with the Father, then an essence must be previously supposed, from
which they have been generated; and that the One is not Father and the
Other Son, but they are brothers together. Cf.
supr. p. 314, note 1, Cyr. Thesaur. pp. 22,
23.’ As to all this, though it be a Greek
interpretation, and what comes from them does not bind us Cf.
p. 169, note 4a [and on οὐσία as a
philosophical and theological term, Prolegg. ch. ii. §3 (2)
b. On the divergence of its theological use from its philosophical
sense, see] Anastasius, Hodeg. 6. and Theorian, Legat. ad
Arm. pp. 441, 2. Socr. iii. 25. Damascene, speaking of the Jacobite
use of φύσις and
ὑπόστασις says, ‘Who of holy men ever thus spoke? unless ye
introduce to us your S. Aristotle, as a thirteenth Apostle, and prefer
the idolater to the divinely inspired.’ cont.
Jacob. 10. p. 399. and so again Leontius, speaking of
Philoponus, who from the Monophysite confusion of nature and hypostasis
was led into Tritheism. ‘He thus argued, taking his start from
Aristotelic principles; for Aristotle says that there are of
individuals particular substances as well as one common.’ De
Sect. v. fin., still let us see whether those things which
are called coessential and are collateral, as derived from one essence
presupposed, are coessential with each other, or with the essence from
which they are generated. For if only with each other, then are they
other in essence and unlike, when referred to that essence which
generated them; for other in essence is opposed to coessential; but if
each be coessential with the essence which generated them, it is
thereby confessed that what is generated from any thing, is coessential
with that which generated it; and there is no need of seeking for three
essences, but merely to seek whether it be true that this is from
that The
argument, when drawn out, is virtually this: if, because two subjects
are coessential, a third is pre-supposed of which they partake, then,
since either of these two is coessential with that of which both
partake, a new third must be supposed in which it and the pre-existing
substance partake and thus an infinite series of things coessential
must be supposed. Vid. Basil. Ep. 52. n. 2. [Cf. Aristot.
Frag. 183, p. 1509 b 23.]. For should it happen that there were not
two brothers, but that only one had come of that essence, he that was
generated would not be called alien in essence, merely because there
was no other from the essence than he; but though alone, he must be
coessential with him that begat him. For what shall we say about
Jephtha’s daughter; because she was only-begotten, and ‘he
had not,’ says Scripture, ‘other child’ (Jud. xi. 34); and again, concerning the
widow’s son, whom the Lord raised from the dead, because he too
had no brother, but was only-begotten, was on that account neither of
these coessential with him that begat? Surely they were, for they were
children, and this is a property of children with reference to their
parents. And in like manner also,
when the Fathers said that the Son of God was from His essence,
reasonably have they spoken of Him as coessential. For the like
property has the radiance compared with the light. Else it follows that
not even the creation came out of nothing. For whereas men beget with
passion Orat. i. §28., so again they work upon an existing
subject matter, and otherwise cannot make. But if we do not understand
creation in a human way Vid.
de Decr. §11, note 6: also Cyril, Thesaur. iv. p.
29: Basil. contr. Eun. ii. 23: Hil. de Syn.
17., when we attribute
it to God, much less seemly is it to understand generation in a human
way, or to give a corporeal sense to Coessential; instead of receding
from things originate, casting away human images, nay, all things
sensible, and ascending Naz.
Orat. 28. 2. to the Father S.
Basil says in like manner that, though God is Father κυρίως properly, supr. p. 156, note 1, 157, note 6, 171,
note 5, 319, note 3), yet it comes to the same thing if we were to say
that He is τροπικῶς and ἐκ
μεταφορᾶς, figuratively, such, contr. Eun. ii.
24; γέννησις implies two things,—passion, and relationship,
οἰκείωσις
φύσεως;
accordingly we must take the latter as an indication of the divine
sense of the term. Cf. also supr. p. 158, note 7, p. 322,
Orat. ii. 32, iii. 18, 67, and Basil. contr.
Eunom. ii. 17; Hil. de Trin. iv. 2. Vid. also Athan.
ad Serap. i. 20. and Basil. Ep. 38. n. 5. and what
is said of the office of faith in each of these., lest we rob the Father of the Son in
ignorance, and rank Him among His own creatures.