Another influence which during the same period
led to a gradual formation of theology was the necessity of defending
the Church against heathenism. If the Gnostics were ‘the first
Christian theologians’ (Harnack), the Apologists (120–200) are more directly important for
our present enquiry. The usual title of Justin ‘Philosopher and
Martyr’ is significant of his position and typical of the class
of writers to which he belongs. On the one hand the Apologists are
philosophers rather than theologians. Christianity is ‘the only
true philosophy’ (Justin); its doctrines are found piecemeal
among the philosophers (λόγος
σπερματικός),
who are so far Christians, just as the Christians are the true
philosophers (Justin and Minuc. Felix). But the Logos, who is imparted
fragmentarily to the philosophers, is revealed in His entire divine
Personality in Christ (so Justin beyond the others, Apol. ii. 8,
10). In the doctrine of God, their thought is coloured by the eclectic
Platonism of the age before Plotinus. God, the Father of all things, is
Creator, Lord, Master, and as such known to man, but in Himself
Unoriginate (ἀγένητος), ineffable,
mysterious (ἄρρητος), without a name, One
and alone, incapable of Incarnation (for references to Justin and to
Plato, D.C.B. iii. 572). His ‘goodness’ is metaphysical
perfection, or beneficence to man, His ‘righteousness’ that
of Moral Governor of the Universe (contrast the deeper sense of St.
Paul, Rom. iii. 21, &c.). But the abstractness of the
conception of God gives way to personal vividness in the doctrine of
the ‘visible God’ (Tert. Prax. 15 sq.), the Logos
(the subject of the O.T. ‘theophanies’ according to the
Apologists) who was ‘with’ the Father before all things
(Just. Dial. 62), but was ‘begotten’ or projected
(προβληθεις)
by the will of the Father (ib. 128) as God from God, as a flame from
fire. He is, like the Father, ineffable (Χριστός, Just.
Apol. ii. 6), yet is the ἄγγελος,
ὑπηρέτης of the
Father. In particular He is the Father’s minister in
Creation: to create He proceeded from the Father, a doctrine
expressly deduced from Prov.
viii. 22 (Dial. 61,
129). Before this He was the λόγος
ἐνδιάθετος,
after it the λόγος
προφορικός,
the Word uttered (Ps. xlv.
1 LXX; this distinction is
not in Justin, but is found Theophil. ad Autol. ii. 10, 22: it
is the most marked trace of philosophic [Stoic] influence on the
Apologists). The Apologists, then, conceive of Christian theology as
philosophers. Especially the Person of the Saviour is regarded by
them from the cosmological, not the soteriological view-point. From the
latter, as we have seen, St. Paul starts; and his view gradually
embraces the distant horizon of the former (1 Cor. viii. 6, Coloss. i. 15); from the soteriological side also
(directly) he reaches the divinity of Christ (Rom. v. 1–8; 1 Cor. i. 30; Rom. x.
13, as above). Here,
as we shall see, Athanasius meets the Arians substantially by St.
Paul’s method. But the Apologists, under the influence of their
philosophy rather than of their religion, start from the cosmological
aspect of the problem. They engraft upon an Apostolic (Johannine) title
of the Saviour an Alexandrine group of associations: they go far
towards transmuting the Word of St. John to the Logos of Philo and the
Eclectics. Hence their view of His Divinity and of his relation to the
Father is embarrassed. His eternity and His generation are felt to be
hardly compatible: His distinct Personality is maintained at the
expense of His true Divinity. He is God, and not the One God; He can
manifest Himself (Theophanies) in a way the One God cannot; He is an
intermediary between God and the world. The question has become
philosophical rather than directly religious, and philosophy cannot
solve it. But on the other hand, Justin was no Arian. If he was
Philosopher, he was also Martyr. The Apologists are deeply saturated
with Christian piety and personal enthusiastic devotion to Christ.
Justin in particular introduces us, as no other so early writer, into
the life, the worship, the simple faith of the Primitive Church, and we
can trace in him influences of the deeper theology of Asia Minor
(Loofs, p. 72 sq. but see more fully the noble article on Justin
in D.C.B. vol. iii.). But our concern is with their influence on the
analysis of the object of faith; and here we see that unconsciously
they have severed the Incarnate Son from the Eternal Father: not God
(ὁ ὄντως θεός)
but a subordinate divine being is revealed in Christ: the Logos,
to adopt the words of Ignatius, is no longer a true breach of the
Divine Silence.