beauty which they saw, now it is too weak to face the rays of the sun; then they had intelli-
gence sufficient to understand a discourse addressed to them, now they have no ability of
the kind; then this astonishing and effective eloquence was natural, now eloquence of the
most meagre kind requires diligent study and preparation. How many good things did the
race of darkness lose by the mixture of good!
11. Faustus has displayed his ingenuity, in the remarks to which I am now replying, by
making for himself a long list of opposites—health and sickness, riches and poverty, white
and black, cold and hot, sweet and bitter. We need not say much about black and white.
Or, if there is a character for good or evil in colors, so that white must be ascribed to God
and black to Hyle; if God threw a white color on the wings of birds, when Hyle, as the
Manichæans say, created them, where had the crows gone to when the swans got whitened?
Nor need we discuss heat and cold, for both are good in moderation, and dangerous in ex-
cess. With regard to the rest, Faustus probably intended that good and evil, which he might
as well have put first, should be understood as including the rest, so that health, riches,
white, hot, sweet, should belong to good; and sickness, poverty, black, cold, bitter, to evil.
The ignorance and folly of this is obvious. It might look like reviling if I were to take up
separately white and black, hot and cold, sweet and bitter, health and sickness. For if white
and sweet are both good, and black and bitter evil, how is it that most grapes and all olives
become black as they become sweet, and so get good by getting evil? And if heat and health
are both good, and cold and sickness evil, why do bodies become sick when heated? Is it
healthy to have fever? But I let these things pass, for they may have been put down hastily,
or they may have been given as merely instances of opposition, and not as being good and
bad, especially as it is nowhere stated that the fire among the race of darkness is cold, so
that heat in this case must unquestionably be evil.
12. We pass on, then, to health, riches, sweetness, which Faustus evidently accounts
good in his contrasts. Was there no health of body in the race of darkness where animals
were born and grew up and brought forth, and had such vitality, that when some that were
with child were taken, as the story is, and were put in bonds in heaven, even the abortive
offspring of a premature birth, falling from heaven to earth, nevertheless lived, and grew,
and produced the innumerable kinds of animals which now exist? Or were there no riches
where trees could grow not only in water and wind, but in smoke and fire, and could bear
such a rich produce, that animals, according to their several kinds, sprang from the fruit,
and were provided with the means of subsistence from those fertile trees, and showed how
well fed they were by a numerous progeny? And all this where there was no toil in cultivation,
and no inclement change from summer to winter, for there was no sun to give variety to
the seasons by his annual course. There must have been perennial productiveness where
the trees were not only born in their own element, but had a supply of appropriate nourish-
ment to make them constantly fertile; as we see orange-trees bearing fruit all the year round
459
Faustus denies that Manichæans believe in two gods. Hyle no god. Augustin…