252 JEROME.
Holy Spirit. He has upset the tables of
Mammon and has scattered the money of the
money-changers ; zealous that the house of
God may be called a house of prayer and not
a den of robbers.1 In his steps follow closely and in those of others like him in virtue,
whom the priesthood makes poor men and
more than ever humble. Or if you will be
perfect, go out with Abraham from your coun-
try and from your kindred, and go whither
you know not.2 If you have substance, sell it and give to the poor. If you have none,
then are you free from a great burthen. Des-
titute yourself, follow a destitute Christ. The
task is a hard one, it is great and difficult ;
but the reward is also great.
LETTER CXXVI.
TO MARCELLINUS AND ANAPSYCHIA.
Marcellinus, a Roman official of high rank, and
Anapsychia his wife had written to Jerome from Africa
to ask him his opinion on the vexed question of the
origin of the soul. Jerome in his reply briefly enumer- ates the several views that have been held on the sub-
ject. For fuller information he refers his questioners
to his treatise against Rufinus and also to their bishop
Augustin who will, he says, explain the matter to them
by word of mouth. Although it hardly appears in this
letter Jerome is a'tlecided creationist (see his Comm. on Eccles. xii. 7). But, though he vehemently condemns
Rufinus (Ap. ii. 10) for professing ignorance on the sub-
ject, he assents (Letter CXXXIV.) to Augustin (Letter
CXXXI.) who similarly professes ignorance but seems to
lean to traducianism. The date of writing is A.D. 412.
To his truly holy lord and lady, his children
worthy of the highest respect and affection,
Marcellinus and Anapsychia, Jerome sends
greeting.
i. I have at last received from Africa your
joint letter and no longer regret the effrontery
which led me, in spite of your silence to ply
you both with so many missives. I hoped,
indeed, by so doing to gain a reply and to
learn of your welfare not indirectly from others
but directly from yourselves.
I well remember your little problem about
the nature of the soul ; although I ought not to
call it little, seeing that it is one of the greatest
with which the church has to deal. You ask
whether it has fallen from heaven, as Pytha-
goras, all Platonists, and Origen suppose ; or
whether it is part of God's essence as the Stoics, Manes, and the Spanish Priscillianists hint.
Whether souls created long since are kept in
God's storehouse as some ecclesiastical writers3 foolishly imagine ; or whether they are formed
by God and introduced into bodies day by day
according to that saying in the Gospel : " my
Father worketh hitherto and I work ; " 4 or
1 John 11. 14-16: Matt. xxi. 12,13. 2 Gen. xii. i: Heb.xi.8. ' The allusion is probably to Clement of Alexandria. 4 John v. 17.
whether, lastly, they are transmitted by prop-
agation. This is the view of Tertullian,
Apollinaris, and most western writers who hold
that soul is derived from soul as body is from
body and that the conditions of life are the
same for men and brutes. I have given my
opinion on the matter in my reply to the
treatise which Rufinus presented to Anasta-
sius, bishop of Rome, of holy memory. He
strives in this by an evasive and crafty but
sufficiently foolish confession to play with the
simplicity of his hearers, but only succeeds in
playing with his own faith or rather want of
it. My book,1 which has been published a good while, contains an answer to the calum-
nies which in his various writings Rufinus
has directed against me. Your reverend
father Oceanus2 has, I think, a copy of it. But if you cannot procure it your bishop
Augustine is both learned and holy. He will
teach you by word of mouth and will give you
his opinion, or rather mine, in his own words.
2. I have long wished to attack the prophe-
cies of Ezekiel and to make good the promises
which I have so often given to curious read-
ers. When, however, I began to dictate I
was so confounded by the havoc wrought in
the West and above all by the sack of Rome
that, as the common saying has it, I forgot
even my own name. Long did I remain silent
knowing that it was a time to weep.3 This year I began again and had written three
books of commentary when a sudden incur-
sion of those barbarians of whom your Virgil
speaks 4 as the " far-wandering men of Barce " (and to whom may be applied what holy script-
ure says of Ishmael : u he shall dwell over
against all his brethren " 5) overran the bor- ders of Egypt, Palestine, Phenicia, and Syria,
and like a raging torrent carried everything
before them. It was with difficulty and only
through Christ's mercy that we were able to escape from their hands. But if, as the great
orator says, " amid the clash of arms law
ceases to be heard ; " * how much more truly may it be said that war puts an end to the
study of holy scripture. For this requires
plenty of books and silence and careful copy- ists and above all freedom from alarm and a
sense of security. I have accordingly only
been able to complete two books and these I
have sent to my daughter, Fabiola,7 from
1 Against Rufinus, ii. §§ 8-10 ; iii. § 30 ; in neither place, how- ever, does Jerome clearly state his own view. 2 See Letter LXIX. introduction. It is doubtful whether
Oceanus was in holy orders although the title ' father ' seems to imply it. 3 Eccl. iii. 4.
4 Virg., A. iv. 43. It does not appear who these barbarians were. Barce is near Cyrene in Africa.
5 Gen. xvi. 12. R.V. marg. • Cicero, pro Milon. 4.
7 This Fabiola (who must be carefully distinguished from the lady so often mentioned by Jerome) is probably the person to
whom Augustine addressed a letter on communion with the spiritual world.