$14 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Boox vu.
away in silence. This one thing I ask, above all, What reason
is there if I kill a pig, that a god changes his state of mind,
and lays aside his angry feelings and frenzy ; that if I con-
sume a pullet, a calf under his eyes and on his altars, he
forgets the wrong [which I did to him], and abandons com-
pletely all sense of displeasure? What passes from this act!
to [modify] his resentment? Or of what service? is a goose,
a goat, or a peacock, that from its blood relief is brought to
the angry [god]? Do the gods, then, make insulting them
a matter of payment? and as little boys, to [induce them to]
give up their fits of passion? and desist from their wailings,
get little sparrows, dolls, ponies, puppets,’ with which they
may be able to divert themselves, do the immortal gods in
such wise receive these gifts from you, that for them they
may lay aside their resentment, and be reconciled to those
who offended them? And yet I thought that the gods—if
only it is right to believe that they are really moved by
anger—lay aside their anger and resentment, and forgive
the sins of the guilty, without any price or reward. For
this belongs specially to deities, to be generous in forgiving,
and to seek no return for their gifts. But if this cannot be,
it would be much wiser that they should continue obstinately
offended, than that they should be softened by being cor-
rupted with bribes. For the multitude increases of those
who sin, when there is hope given of paying for their sin ;
and there is little hesitation to do wrong, when the favour of
those who pardon [offences] may be bought.
9. So, if some ox, or any animal you please, which is
slain to mitigate and appease the fury of the deities, were to
take a man's voice and speak these? words: Is this, then, O
Jupiter, or whatever god thou art, humane or right, or
should it be considered at all just, that when another has
1 Lit., ** work." ? Lit., ** remedy.”
3 So Panes seems to be generally understood, i.e. images of Pan used
as playthings by boys, and very much the same thing as the puppets—
pupuli—already mentioned.
* Lit., ** to have liberal pardons and free concessions."
5 Lit., ** in these."