Some
critics (as Meyer, Olshausen) have affirmed the opposite of what Chrys.
states, in regard to the ὁι ἐκ
περιτομῆς. He excludes the apostles from this category; they would
include them. The ὁι ἐκ
περιτομῆς, however, seem to have been a special class of Christians
in the mind of the writer. In expressing the fact that the Church
learned of the reception of the Gentiles, the “apostles and
brethren” are named, but when the narrative advances to the
thought of the contention against Peter on account of it, a new
term is chosen; the writer could not allow the same subject to stand
for the verb διεκρίνοντο, but chooses another term—ὁι
ἐκ
περιτομῆς. The two subjects, then, can hardly be identical. The
phrase more probably denotes judaizing Christians, i.e. those who gave
special prominence to the Law and the necessity of circumcision (So
Lechler, Gloag, Alford).—G.B.S.