(1) Death of Athanasius. It is superfluous
to discuss this date at the present day, but it may be worth while to
point out for the last time how admirably the combined testimony of our
chronicles confirms the judgment of the best critics (Montfaucon,
Tillemont, &c.) antecedent to their discovery, and how clearly the
secondary value to be assigned to the chronological statements of
Socrates and Sozomen once more comes out (Socr. iv. 21 puts the date at
371, and was followed by Papebroke, Petavius and others (fuller details
and discussion of the question on its ancient footing in Newman’s
preface to Hist. Tracts of St. Athan., pp. xx., sqq.).
But no one any longer questions the date of May 2–3, 373. The
fact that the Hist. Aceph. gives May 3 and the Index May
2 (the date observed in the later calendars) vouches for the
independence of the two documents and for the very early date of the
former: probably, as Sievers and others suggest, the true date is the
night between May 2 and May 3.