But by this mode of denial I
criminate myself; for bringing Virgil as my witness I am accused by my
own defender. I suppose I must weave a long web of words to prove what
each man is conscious of. Which of us does not remember his infancy? I
shall make you laugh though you are a man of such extreme gravity; and
you will have at last to do as Crassus did, who, Lucilius tells us,
laughed but once in his life, if I recount the memories of my
childhood: how I ran about among the offices where the slaves worked;
how I spent the holidays in play; or how I had to be dragged like a
captive from my grandmother’s lap to the lessons of my enraged
Orbilius. The name of a pedagogue recorded by Horace (Ep. ii, 1, 71), which
passed into a general name for boys’ tutors. You may still more be astonished if
I say that, even now that my head is gray and bald, I often seem in my
dreams to be standing, a curly youth, dressed in my toga, to declaim a
controversial thesis before the master of rhetoric; and, when I wake, I
congratulate myself on escaping the peril of making a speech. Believe
me, our infancy brings back to us many things most accurately. If you
had had a literary education, your mind would retain what it was
originally imbued with as a wine cask retains its scent. The purple dye
on the wool cannot be washed out with water. Even asses and other
brutes know the inns they have stopped at before, however long the
journey may have been. Are you astonished that I have not forgotten my
Latin books when you learnt Greek without a master? I learned the seven
forms of Syllogisms in the Elements of logic; I learned the meaning of
an Axiom, or as it might be called in Latin a Determination; I learned
how every sentence must have in it a verb and a noun; how to heap up
the steps of the Sorites, The “Heap-argument,” in which a number of separate
arguments converge on the same point. how to detect
the clever turns of the Pseudomenos “The Liar,” another logical puzzle. and the
frauds of the stock sophisms. I can swear that I never read any of
these things after I left school. I suppose that, to escape from having
what I learned made into a crime, I must, according to the fables of
the poets, go and drink of the river Lethe. I summon you, who
accuse me for my scanty knowledge, and who think yourself a
litérateur and a Rabbi, tell me how was it that you dared to write
some of the things you have written, and to translate Gregory, Nazianzen. See Prolegomena. that most eloquent man, with a splendour
of eloquence like his own? Whence have you obtained that flow of words,
that lucidity of statement, that variety of translations,—you who
in youth had hardly more than a first taste of rhetoric? I must be very
much mistaken if you do not study Cicero in secret. I suspect that,
being yourself so cultivated a person, you forbid me under penalties
the reading of Cicero, so that you may be left alone among our church
writers to boast of your flow of eloquence. I must say, however, that
you seem rather to follow the philosophers, for your style is akin to
that of the thorny sentences of Cleanthes Stoic philosopher of Assus in Lydia b.c.
300–240.
and the contortions of Chrysippus, Of Cilicia; disciple of Cleanthes, b.c.
280–208. not from
any art, for of that you say you are ignorant, but from the sympathy of
genius. The Stoics claim Logic as their own, a science which you
despise as a piece of fatuity; on this side, therefore, you are an
Epicurean, and the principle of your eloquence is, not style but
matter. For, indeed, what does it matter that no one else understands
what you wish to say, when you write for your own friends alone, not
for all? I must confess that I myself do not always understand what you
write, and think that I am reading Born at Ephesus b.c. 503. His philosophy
was tinged with melancholy, and his style obscure.
Heraclitus; however I do not complain, nor lament for my sluggishness;
for the trouble of reading what you write is not more than the trouble
you must have in writing it.