Testimonia

Publiek archief van verzamelde en verwerkte bronrecords.
Overzicht / tekstblob

Tekstblob

sha256: 74ecc2bf147d6e1bcd2f86e7a7f69c590e35f1952db46586e706e62a67ba3f75 · 2,178 tekens

234 MEMORIALS OF TWO SISTERS [1862-67 that they know stealing and murder to be wrong, though they may commit such acts and try to justify the in- dividual case ; and all who have to deal with the most degraded classes amongst ourselves insist strenuously that there is " something to appeal to " in them all ; that they do recognize certain laws of right and wrong, and recognize many that they do not act upon. Thus the sources of disagreement in moral judgment seem to me to be three : First, the differences in the whole development and culture of the man or race, upon which depend, in morals as in other modes of thought, his range and keen- ness of perception, and power of tracing out consequences; secondly, the directly disturbing force of self-interest as far as we can make out, Thugs do not think murder in itself a right and laudable institution, but they think the destructive principle so mighty in this world that on the whole they choose, for their own safety, to be on that side rather than on the other ; thirdly, that even where the stages of development may not differ widely, two minds may form different judgments on a case, because, in fact, the same case is not present to them both. Have you not noticed how lawyers, in trying a case, pare off one circumstance after another till they get a distinct issue, and get a judgment on that ? In daily life any case you can put involves more than one, often a great number, of these issues, and in discussions as to the right course to be taken you will constantly see that one person is giving judgment on one of these issues, and another on some other. If you think it over, you will see how this is eminently true of such complex institutions as laws of sacrifice or laws of marriage. Here all hangs on the power of discovering what is the highest and governing condition among the number of considerations present. But that some men or nations do not get beyond a lower aspect of the truth, does not prove that there is no truth to be arrived at. And whenever the same case really is pre- sented to a number of minds, the unanimity of judgment is surely marvellous. Courage, self-sacrifice, loyalty, love

Alle records · Zoek op deze hash