19. And first let us see the answers, which they
returned to Alexander of blessed memory, in the outset, while their
heresy was in course of formation. They wrote thus: ‘He is a
creature, but not as one of the creatures; a work, but not as one of
the works; an offspring, but not as one of the offsprings Vid.
Arius’s letter, de Syn. 16. This was the sophism by means
of which Valens succeeded with the Fathers of Arminium. vid. S. Jerome
in Luciferian. 18. vid. also in Eusebius, supr. Ep. Eus.
6..’ Let every one consider the
profligacy and craft of this heresy; for knowing the bitterness of its
own malignity, it makes an effort to trick itself out with fair words,
and says, what indeed it means, that He is a creature, yet thinks to be
able to screen itself by adding, ‘but not as one of the
creatures.’ However, in thus writing, they rather convict
themselves of irreligion; for if, in your opinion, He is simply a
creature, why add the pretence De
Syn. 32., ‘but not as
one of the creatures?’ And if He is simply a work, how ‘not
as one of the works?’ In which we may see the poison of the
heresy. For by saying, ‘offspring, but not as one of the
offsprings,’ they reckon many sons, and one of these they
pronounce to be the Lord; so that according to them He is no more Only
begotten, but one out of many brethren, and is called υἵον
χρηματίζειν. The question between Catholics and Arians was whether our
Lord was a true Son, or only called Son. ‘Since they
whisper something about Word and Wisdom as only names of the
Son, &c.’ ὀνόματα
μόνον, supr.
i. 26, note 1, and de Decr. 16, note 10. And so ‘the title
of Image is not a token of a similar substance, but His name
only,’ supr. i. 21, and so infr. 38. where
τοῖς
ὀνόμασι is
synonymous with κατ᾽
ἐπίνοιαν, as Sent. D. 22. f. a. Vid. also 39. Orat. iii. 11.
18. ‘not named Son, but ever Son,’ iv. 24. fin. Ep.
Æg. 16. ‘We call Him so, and mean truly what we say;
they say it, but do not confess it.’ Chrysost. in Act.
Hom. 33. 4. vid. also νόθοις
ὥσπερ
ὀνόμασι,
Cyril. de Trin. ii. p. 418. Non hæc nuda nomina, Ambros.
de Fid. i. 17. Yet, since the Sabellians equally failed here,
also considering the Sonship as only a notion or title, vid.
Orat. iv. 2. (where in contrast, ‘The Father is Father,
and the Son Son,’ vid. supr. p. 319, note 1.) 12. 23. 25. the
word ‘real’ was used as against them, and in
opposition to ἀνυπόστατος
λόγος by the Arians,
and in consequence failed as a test of orthodox teaching; e.g. by
Arius, supr. p. 97. by Euseb. in Marc. pp. 19, d. 35, b.
161, c. by Asterius, infr. 37. by Palladius and Secundus in the
Council of Aquileia ap. Ambros. Opp. t. 2. p. 791. (ed. Bened.)
by Maximinus ap. August. contr. Max. i. 6. offspring and son. What use then is this
pretence of saying that He is a creature and not a creature? for though
ye shall say, Not as ‘one of the creatures,’ I will prove
this sophism of yours to be foolish. For still ye pronounce Him to be
one of the creatures; and whatever a man might say of the other
creatures, such ye hold concerning the Son, ye truly ‘fools and
blind Matt. xxiii.
19..’ For is any one of the creatures just
what another is And
so S. Ambrose, Quæ enim creatura non sicut alia creatura non est?
Homo non ut Angelus, terra non ut cœlum. de Fid. i. n. 130,
and a similar passage in Nyss. contr. Eun. iii. p. 132,
3., that ye should
predicate this of the Son as some prerogative ἐξαίρετον. vid. infr. Orat. iii. 3. init. iv. 28. init. Euseb.
Eccl. Theol. pp. 47. b. 73. b. 89. b. 124. a. 129. c. Theodor.
H. E. p. 732. Nyss. contr. Eunom. iii. p. 133. a. Epiph.
Hær. 76. p. 970. Cyril. Thes. p. 160.?
And all the visible creation was made in six days:—in the first,
the light which He called day; in the second the firmament; in the
third, gathering together the waters, He bared the dry land, and
brought out the various fruits that are in it; and in the fourth, He
made the sun and the moon and all the host of the stars; and on the
fifth, He created the race of living things in the sea, and of birds in
the air; and on the sixth, He made the quadrupeds on the earth, and at
length man. And ‘the invisible things of Him from the creation of
the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are
made Rom. i. 20.;’ and neither the light is as the
night, nor the sun as the moon; nor the irrational as rational man; nor
the Angels as the Thrones, nor the Thrones as the Authorities, yet they
are all creatures, but each of the things made according to its kind
exists and remains in its own
essence, as it was made.