6. Moreover, as to his assertion, that the reason of the apostles eating on the seventh
day (a thing forbidden by the tradition of the elders) was, that the time for their fasting on
that day had not come; I ask, if the time had not then come for the abolition of the Jewish
rest from work on that day? Did not the tradition of the elders prohibit fasting on the one
hand, and enjoin rest on the other? and.yet the disciples of Christ, of whom we read that
they did eat on the Sabbath, did on the same day pluck the ears of corn, which was not then
lawful, because forbidden by the tradition of the elders. Let him therefore consider whether
it might not with more reason be said in reply to him, that the Lord desired to have these
two things, the plucking of the ears of corn and the taking of food, done in the same day by
His disciples, for this reason, that the former action might confute those who would prohibit
all work on the seventh day, and the latter action confute those who would enjoin fasting
on the seventh day; since by the former action He taught that the rest from labour was now,
through the change in the dispensation, an act of superstition; and by the latter He intimated
His will, that under both dispensations the matter of fasting or not was left to every man’s
choice. I do not say this by way of argument in support of my view, but only to show how,
in answer to him, things much more forcible than what he has spoken might be advanced.
Chap. IV.
7. “How shall we,” says our author, “escape sharing the condemnation of the Pharisee,
if we fast twice in the week?”1577 As if the Pharisee had been condemned for fasting twice
in the week, and not for proudly vaunting himself above the publican. He might as well say
that those also are condemned with that Pharisee, who give a tenth of all their possessions
to the poor, for he boasted of this among his other works; whereas I would that it were done
by many Christians, instead of a very small number, as we find. Or let him say, that whosoever
is not an unjust man, or adulterer, or extortioner, must be condemned with that Pharisee,
because he boasted that he was none of these; but the man who could think thus is, beyond
question, beside himself. Moreover, if these things which the Pharisee mentioned as found
in him, being admitted by all to be good in themselves, are not to be retained with the
haughty boastfulness which was manifest in him, but are to be retained with the lowly piety
which was not in him; by the same rule, to fast twice in the week is in a man such as the
Pharisee unprofitable, but is in one who has humility and faith a religious service. Moreover,
after all, the Scripture does not say that the Pharisee was condemned, but only that the
publican was “justified rather than the other.”
8. Again, when our author insists upon interpreting, in connection with this matter, the
words of the Lord, “Except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the scribes
and Pharisees, ye shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven,”1578 and thinks that we cannot
1577 Luke xviii. 11, 12.
1578 Matt. v. 21.
611
To Casulanus