But when our Lord and Saviour himself was by his
questions instructing the faith of the disciples, he said, “Whom
do men say that I the Son of Man am?” And when they had
mentioned various opinions held by others, he said, “But whom say
ye that I am?” that is, “I who am Son of Man, and whom you
see in the form of a servant, and in reality of flesh, whom say ye that
I am?” Whereupon the blessed Peter, as inspired by God, and
about to benefit all nations by his confession, said, “Thou art
the Christ, the Son of the living God.” Not undeservedly,
therefore, was he pronounced blessed by the Lord, and derived from the
original Rock that solidity which belonged both to his virtue and to
his name, who through revelation from the Father confessed the selfsame
to be both the Son of God and the Christ; because one of these truths,
accepted without the other, would not profit unto salvation, and it was
equally dangerous to believe the Lord Jesus Christ to be merely God and
not man, or merely man and not God. But after the resurrection of
the Lord—which was in truth the resurrection of a real body, for
no other person was raised again than he who had been crucified and had
died—what else was accomplished during that interval of forty
days than to make our faith entire and clear of all darkness? For
while he conversed with his disciples, and dwelt with them, and ate
with them, and allowed himself to be handled with careful and
inquisitive touch by those who were under the influence of doubt, for
this end he came in to the disciples when the doors were shut, and by
his breath gave them the Holy Ghost, and opened the secrets of Holy
Scripture after bestowing on them the light of intelligence, and again
in his selfsame person showed to them the wound in the side, the prints
of the nails, and all the flesh tokens of the Passion, saying,
“Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself; handle me and
see, for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me
have:” that the properties of the Divine and the human
nature might be acknowledged to remain in him without causing a
division, and that we might in such sort know that the Word is not what
the flesh is, as to confess that the one Son of God is both Word and
flesh. On which mystery of the faith this Eutyches must be
regarded as unhappily having no hold, who does not recognise our nature
to exist in the Only-begotten Son of God, either by way of the
lowliness of mortality, or of the glory of resurrection. Nor has
he been overawed by the declaration of the blessed Apostle and
Evangelist John, saying, “Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus
Christ has come in the flesh is of God; and every spirit which
dissolveth Jesus is not of God, and this is Antichrist.”
Now what is to dissolve Jesus, but to separate the human nature from
him, and to make void by shameless inventions that mystery by which
alone we have been saved? Moreover, being in the dark as to the
nature of Christ’s body, he must needs be involved in the like
senseless blindness with regard to his Passion also. For if he
does not think the Lord’s crucifixion to be unreal, and does not
doubt that he really accepted suffering, even unto death, for the sake
of the world’s salvation; as he believes in his death, let him
acknowledge his flesh also, and not doubt that he whom he recognises as
having been capable of suffering is also Man with a body like ours;
since to deny his true flesh is also to deny his bodily
sufferings. If then he accepts the Christian faith, and does not
turn away his ear from the preaching of the Gospel, let him see what
nature it was that was transfixed with nails and hung on the wood of
the cross; and let him understand whence it was that, after the side of
the Crucified had been pierced by the soldier’s spear, blood and
water flowed out, that the Church of God might be refreshed both with a
Laver and with a Cup. Let him listen also to the blessed Apostle
Peter when he declares, that “sanctification by the Spirit”
takes place through the “sprinkling of the blood of
Christ,” and let him not give a mere cursory reading to the words
of the same Apostle, “Knowing that ye were not redeemed with
corruptible things, as silver and gold, from your vain way of life
received by tradition from your fathers, but with the precious blood of
Jesus Christ as of a Lamb without
blemish and without spot.” Let him also not resist the
testimony of Blessed John the Apostle, “And the blood of Jesus
the Son of God cleanseth us from all sin.” And again,
“This is the victory which overcometh the world, even our
faith;” and, “who is he that overcometh the world, but he
that believeth that Jesus is the Son of God? This is he that came
by water and blood, even Jesus Christ; not in water only, but in water
and blood; and it is the Spirit that beareth witness, because the
Spirit is truth. For there are three that bear witness—the
Spirit, the water, and the blood; and the three are one.”
That is, the Spirit of sanctification, and the blood of redemption, and
the water of baptism; which three things are one, and remain undivided,
and not one of them is disjoined from connection with the others;
because the Catholic Church lives and advances by this faith, that
Christ Jesus we should believe neither manhood to exist without true
Godhead, nor Godhead without true manhood. But when Eutyches, on
being questioned in your examination of him, answered, “I confess
that our Lord was of two natures before the union, but after the union
I confess one nature;” I am astonished that so absurd and
perverse a profession as this of his was not rebuked by a censure on
the part of any of his judges, and that an utterance extremely foolish
and extremely blasphemous was passed over, just as if nothing had been
heard which could give offence: seeing that it is as impious to
say that the Only-begotten Son of God was of two natures before the
Incarnation as it is shocking to affirm that, since the Word became
flesh, there has been in him one nature only. But lest Eutyches
should think that what he said was correct, or was tolerable, because
it was not confuted by any assertion of yours, we exhort your earnest
solicitude, dearly beloved brother, to see that, if by God’s
merciful inspiration the case is brought to a satisfactory issue, the
inconsiderate and inexperienced man be cleansed also from this
pestilent notion of his; seeing that, as the record of the proceedings
has clearly shown, he had fairly begun to abandon his own opinion when
on being driven into a corner by authoritative words of yours, he
professed himself ready to say what he had not said before, and to give
his adhesion to that faith from which he had previously stood
aloof. But when he would not consent to anathematize the impious
dogma you understood, brother, that he continued in his own misbelief,
and deserved to receive sentence of condemnation. For which if he
grieves sincerely and to good purpose, and understands, even though too
late, how properly the Episcopal authority has been put in motion, or
if, in order to make full satisfaction, he shall condemn viva
voce, and under his own hand, all that he has held amiss, no
compassion, to whatever extent, which can be shown him when he has been
set right, will be worthy of blame, for our Lord, the true and good
Shepherd, who laid down his life for his sheep, and who came to save
men’s souls and not to destroy them, wills us to imitate his own
loving kindness; so that justice should indeed constrain those who sin,
but mercy should not reject those who are converted. For then
indeed is the true faith defended with the best results, when a false
opinion is condemned even by those who have followed it. But in
order that the whole matter may be piously and faithfully carried out,
we have appointed our brethren, Julius, Bishop, and Reatus, Presbyter
(of the title of St. Clement) and also my son Hilarus, Deacon, to
represent us; and with them we have associated Dulcitius, our Notary,
of whose fidelity we have had good proof: trusting that the
Divine assistance will be with you, so that he who has gone astray may
be saved by condemning his own unsound opinion. May God keep you
in good health, dearly beloved brother. Given on the Ides of
June, in the Consulate of the illustrious men, Asterius and
Protogenes.