Let us however resume
Eunomius’ statement in its entirety. “Having come into
being from the only God through the Only-begotten, this Spirit
also—” What proof is there of the statement that
“this Spirit also” is one of the things that were made by
the Only-begotten? They will say of course that “all things were
made by Him Cf.
S. John i. 3,” and that in the term “all
things” “this Spirit also” is included. Our answer to
them shall be this, All things were made by Him, that were made. Now
the things that were made, as Paul tells us, were things visible and
invisible, thrones, authorities, dominions, principalities, powers, and
among those included under the head of thrones and powers are reckoned
by Paul the Cherubim and Seraphim Cf. Col. i. 16; but the enumeration varies considerably.: so far does the
term “all things” extend. But of the Holy Spirit, as being
above the nature of things that have come into being, Paul said not a
word in his enumeration of existing things, not indicating to us by his
words either His subordination or His coming into being; but just as
the prophet calls the Holy Spirit “good,” and
“right,” and “guiding The
last of these epithets is from Ps. li. 14 (πνεῦμα
ἡγεμονικὸν, the “Spiritus principalis” of the Vulgate,
the “free spirit” of the English version); the “right
spirit” of ver.
12 being also applied by S. Gregory to the Holy Spirit, while the
epithet “good” is from Ps. cxlii. 10.” (indicating by the word
“guiding” the power of control), even so the apostle
ascribes independent authority to the dignity of the Spirit, when he
affirms that He works all in all as He wills Cf. 1 Cor. xii. 11..
Again, the Lord makes manifest the Spirit’s independent power and
operation in His discourse with Nicodemus, when He says, “The
Spirit breatheth where He willeth S. John iii. 8.” How is
it then that Eunomius goes so far as to define that He also is one of
the things that came into being by the Son, condemned to eternal
subjection. For he describes Him as “once for all made
subject,” enthralling the guiding and governing Spirit in I know
not what form of subjection. For this expression of
“subjection” has many significations in Holy Scripture, and
is understood and used with many varieties of meaning. For the Psalmist
says that even irrational nature is put in subjection Ps. viii. 7,
8.,
and brings under the same term those who are overcome in war Ps. xlvii. 3., while the apostle bids servants to be in
subjection to their own masters Tit. ii. 9., and that those who
are placed over the priesthood should have their children in
subjection 1 Tim. iii. 4., as their disorderly conduct brings
discredit upon their fathers, as in the case of the sons of Eli the
priest. Again, he speaks of the subjection of all men to God, when we
all, being united to one another by the faith, become one body of the
Lord Who is in all, as the subjection of the Son to the Father, when
the adoration paid to the Son by all things with one accord, by things
in heaven, and things on earth, and things under the earth, redounds to
the glory of the Father; as Paul says elsewhere, “To Him every
knee shall bow, of things in heaven, and things in earth, and things
under the earth, and every tongue shall confess that Jesus Christ is
Lord, to the glory of God the Father Cf. Phil. ii. 10, 11, a passage which is
apparently considered as explanatory of 1 Cor. xv. 28..” For when
this takes place, the mighty wisdom of Paul affirms that the Son, Who
is in all, is subject to the Father by virtue of the subjection of
those in whom He is. What kind of “subjection once for all”
Eunomius asserts of the Holy Spirit, it is thus impossible to learn
from the phrase which he has thrown out,—whether he means the
subjection of irrational creatures, or of captives, or of servants, or
of children who are kept in order, or of those who are saved by
subjection. For the subjection of men to God is salvation for those who
are so made subject, according to the voice of the prophet, who says
that his soul is subject to God, since of Him cometh salvation by
subjection Cf. Ps. lxii. 1 (LXX.)., so that subjection is the means of
averting perdition. As therefore the help of the healing art is sought
eagerly by the sick, so is subjection by those who are in need of
salvation. But of what life does the Holy Spirit, that quickeneth all
things, stand in need, that by subjection He should obtain salvation
for Himself? Since then it is not on the strength of any Divine
utterance that he asserts such an attribute of the Spirit, nor yet is
it as a consequence of probable arguments that he has launched this
blasphemy against the Holy Spirit, it must be plain at all events to
sensible men that he vents his impiety against Him without any warrant
whatsoever, unsupported as it is by any authority from Scripture or by
any logical consequence.