332 JEROME.
bring forth the vessels of wrath ; and, as they
depart, the saints will say,1 "They went out from us, but they were not of us ; for if they
had been of us, they would no doubt have
continued with us." No one can take to him-
self the prerogative of Christ, no one before
the day of judgment can pass judgment upon
men. If the Church is already cleansed, what
shall we reserve for the Lord ? 2 " There is a
way which seemeth right unto a man, but the
end thereof are the ways of death." When our judgment is so prone to error, upon whose
opinion can we rely ?
23. Cyprian of blessed memory tried to avoid broken cisterns and not to drink of
strange waters : and therefore, rejecting
heretical baptism, he summoned his 3 African
synod in opposition to Stephen,4 who was the
blessed Peter's twenty-second successor in the see of Rome. They met to discuss this mat-
ter ; but the attempt failed. At last those
very bishops who had together with him de-
termined that heretics must be re-baptized,
reverted to the old custom and published a
fresh decree. Do you ask what course we
must pursue ? What we do our forefathers handed down to us as their forefathers to
them. But why speak of later times ? When
the blood of Christ was but lately shed and
the apostles were still in Judaea, the Lord's body was asserted to be a phantom ; the Gala- tians had been led away to the observance of
the law, and the Apostle was a second time in
travail with them ; the Corinthians did not
believe the resurrection of the flesh, and he
endeavoured by many arguments to bring them
back to the right path. Then came 6 Simon Magus and his disciple Menander. They
asserted themselves to be " powers of God.
Then ' Basilides invented the most high god
A&raxas and the three hundred and sixty-five
manifestations of him. Then b Nicolas, one of the seven Deacons, and one whose lech-
ery knew no rest by night or day, indulged
in his filthy dreams. I say nothing Of the
Jewish heretics who before the coming of
Christ destroyed the law delivered to them :
of 9 Dositheus, the leader of the Samaritans
1 i John ii. 19. 2 Prov. xiv. 12.
3 Stephen was willing to admit all heretical baptism, even that by Marcionites and Ophites ; Cyprian would admit none. The
Council was held at Carthage A. D. 255, and was followed by two in the next year.
4 Bishop of Rome from May 12, A. D. 254, to Aug. 2, A. D. 257. See note on ch. 25.
5 The words of i John iv. 3 would appear to support Jerome's remark.
6 Acts viii. 10. In the Clementine Homilies and Recognitions Simon is the constant opponent of St. Peter.
7 Commonly regarded as the chief among the Egyptian Gnos- tics. The Basilidian system is described by Irenaeus (joif).
B Acts vi. 5, Rev. ii. 6, 15. As to how far Jerome's estimate of the character of Nicolas is correct, the article Nicolas in
Smith's Diet, of Bible may be consulted. 9 Jerome here reproduces almost exactly the remark of Pseudo- Tertullian. The Dositheans were probably a Jewish or Sa- maritan ascetic sect, something akin to the Essenes.
who rejected the prophets : of the Sadducees
who sprang from his root and denied even the resurrection of the flesh : of the Pharisees who
separated themselves from the Jews ' on ac- count of certain superfluous observances, and
took their name from the fact of their dissent :
of the Herodians who accepted Herod as the
Christ. I come to those heretics who have
mangled the Gospels, 2 Saturninus, and the
3 Ophites, 4 the Cainites and " Sethites, and
6 Carpocrates, and ' Cerinthus, and his suc-
cessor 8 Ebion, and the other pests, the most of which broke out while the apostle John was
still alive, and yet we do not read that any of
these men were re-baptized.
24. As we have made mention of that dis-
tinguished saint, let us show also from his
Apocalypse tha*t repentance unaccompanied by baptism ought to be allowed valid in the
case of heretics. It is imputed (Rev. ii. 4)
to the angel of Ephesus that he has forsaken
his first love. In the angel of the Church of
Pergamum the eating of idol-sacrifices is cen-
sured (Rev. ii. 14), and the doctrine of the
Nicolaitans (ib. 15). Likewise the angel of
Thyatira is rebuked (ib. 20) on account of
Jezebel the prophetess, and the idol meats,
and fornication. And yet the Lord encour-
ages all these to repent, and adds a threat,
moreover, of future punishment if they do
not turn. Now he would not urge them
to repent unless he intended to grant pardon
1 The name Pharisee implies separation, but in the sense of dedication to God.
2 Of Antioch. One of the earliest of the Gnostics (second cen- tury).
3 The Ophites, whose name is derived from c>$is, a serpent, were a sect which lasted from the second century to the sixth.
Some of them believed that the serpent of Gen. iii. was either
the Divine Wisdom, or the Chrisi himself, come to enlighten
mankind. Their errors may in great measure, like those of the
Cainites, be traced to the belief, common to all systems of Gnos- ticism, that the Creator of the world, who was the God of
the Jews, was not the same as the Supreme Being, but was in
antagonism to Him. They supposed that the Scriptures were written in the interest of the Demiurge or Creator, and that a
false colouring being given to the story, the real worthies were
those who are reprobated in the sacred writings.
1 The Cainites regarded as saints, Cain, Korah, Dathan, the
Sodomites, and even the traitor Judas. 6 The Sethites are said to have looked upon Seth as the same
person as Christ.
" Carpocrates, another Gnostic, held that our Lord was the son of Joseph and Mary, and was distinguished from other men
by nothing except moral superiority. He also taught the indif- ference of actions in themselves, and maintained that they take
their quality from opinion or from legislation ; he advocated
community of goods and of wives, basing his views on the doc- trine of natural rights. See Mosheim, Cent. ii.
7 Cerinthus was a native of Judaea, and after having studied at Alexandria established himself as a teacher in his own
country. He afterwards removed to Ephesus, and there became
prominent. He held that Jesus and the Christ were not the
same person ; Jesus was, he said, a real man, the son of Joseph and Marv ; the Christ was an emanation which descended upon
Jesus at his baptism to reveal the Most High, but which for- sook him before the Passion. S. John in his Gospel and Epistles
combats this error. See Westcott's Introduction to i John, p.
xxxiv. (second ed.) etc. Cerinthus is said to have been the here- tic with whom S. John refused to be under the same roof at the bath. To him as author is also referred the doctrine of the Millennium.
H The Ebionites were mere humanitarians. Whether Ebion
ever existed, or whether the sect took its name from the beg-
garlzness of their doctrine, or their vow of poverty, or the poor- ness of spirit which they professed, is disputed.