Although apparently composed at different times
(see above) the four ‘Discourses’ form a single work. The
fourth alone ends with the usual doxology, thus announcing itself as
the conclusion of the four-fold treatise. At the same time, the
relation of the fourth Discourse to the others is by no means clear. It
is largely occupied with a polemic against a heresy at the opposite
extreme from Arianism, Monarchianism in one or other of its forms.
Newman, in his introductory excursus, expresses the opinion that it
consists of a series of fragmentary notes against several heresies,
which for some unknown reason came to be incorporated, possibly by
Athanasius himself or by his secretaries, in the great anti-Arian
Manifesto. Zahn Marcell. pp. 198–208 shews convincingly
that the system of Marcellus, either in itself or in its supposed
logical consequences, is the main object of criticism all along. If we
trace throughout the Discourses the purpose of conciliating the
‘Conservative’ and Semi-Arian party, we can well understand
that Athanasius may have appended to them a section directed against
Monarchianism, which, in the persons of Marcellus and Photinus (whose
names, however, are characteristically absent), must have been felt by
him to be a legitimate stumbling-block in their path toward peace. At
any rate the fourth oration has always been associated with the others
as forming part of one work.