We have lately had a rule against judging others. (Proverbs 18:13 .) Here we are warned against justifying ourselves. Self-flattery is our cherished nature; highly valuing our fancied excellences; very blind to our real imperfections. So ready are we to place our own cause in a strong light; and sometimes, almost unconsciously, to cast a shade over, or even omit, what might seem to balance on the opposite side. It is so difficult to state facts and circumstances with perfect accuracy, where our own name, or credit is concerned. Hence, our cause, coming first, seemeth just. But, according to the proverb, 'the first tale is good, till the second is heard.' Our neighbour, acquainted with the real case, cometh and searcheth us, exposes our fallacy, and puts us to shame.
Often has the tale of wrongs from a hard-hearted overseer, landlord, or creditor, roused our indignation, and perhaps provoked our remonstrance. But the searching process of the story on the other side has shewn us the wrongness of a hasty, one-sided judgment.
Saul made himself appear just in his own cause. The necessity of the case seemed to warrant the deviation from the command. But Samuel searched him, and laid open his rebellion. (1 Samuel 15:17-23 .) Ziba's cause seemed just in David's eyes, until Mephibosheth's explanation searched him to his confusion.†1 Job's incautious self-defense was laid open by Elihu's probing application. (Job 33:8-12 .) An eloquent advocate may easily make a bad cause coming first seem just. But the plaintiff is always right, till the defendant's case has been opened . Yet the true rule of justice would be, to judge neither to be right, till both sides have been heard. Let the whole evidence be sifted; and often the plausible cover is swept away by a more searching investigation. (Acts 24:5, Acts 24:12 .) Judges are bound to "consider, take advice, and speak," ; carefully guarding against prejudging the cause, till the whole has been fully before them; else he that is last in the cause comes with disadvantage, though it may be the cause of right.
In our own cause, always be alive to conviction. Watch against a self-justifying spirit.
Cultivate the spirit of self-distrust. Balance our enemy's statement against our own prejudices. Judge as under the eye of God, and with the sincere anxious prayer to lay ourselves open to his searching disclosure of hidden evil. Deceit in any form never answers its end. "A conscience void of offense both towards God and man" must be our great exercise. (Acts 24:16 .)
Footnotes:
†1 2 Samuel 16:1-4 ; 2 Samuel 19:26 . Compare Proverbs 28:11 . See Bishop Sanderson's Sermons on Job, Job 29:14-17 . Proverbs 24:10-12 .