5. For you have made it sufficiently plain to me that
you disapprove of those who assert that men’s souls are derived
from that of the protoplast i.e. Adam,
“our first-formed father.” (Wisd. x. 1.) and propagated
from one generation to another; but as your letter does not inform me,
I have no means of knowing on what grounds and from what passages of
scripture you have shewn this view to be false. What does commend
itself to you is not clear either from your letter to the brothers at
Cæsarea or from that which you have lately addressed to me. Only I
see that you believe and write that “God has been, is, and will
be the maker of men, and that there is nothing either in heaven or on
earth which does not owe its existence wholly to Him.” This is of
course a truism which nobody can call in question. But as you affirm
that souls are not propagated, you ought to explain out of what God
makes them. Is it out of some pre-existing material, or is it out of
nothing? For it is impossible that you should hold the opinion of
Origen, Priscillian, and other heretics that it is for deeds
done in a former life that souls are confined in earthly and mortal
bodies. This opinion is, indeed, flatly contradicted by the apostle who
says of Jacob and Esau that before they were born they had done neither
good nor evil. Rom. ix. 11. Your view of
the matter, then, is known to me though only partially, but of your
reasons for supposing it to be true I know nothing. This was why in a
former letter I asked you to send me your confession of faith, the one
which you were vexed to find that one of your presbyters had signed
dishonestly. I now again ask you for this, as well as for any passages
of scripture which you have brought to bear on the question. For you
say in your letter to the brothers
at Cæsarea that you “have resolved to have all definitions
of dogma reviewed by lay judges, sitting by general invitation, and
investigating all points touching the faith.” And you continue:
“the divine mercy has made it possible for them to put forward
their views in a positive and definite form, which your modest ability
has reinforced with a great weight of evidence.” Now it is this
“great weight of evidence” which I am so anxious to obtain.
For, so far as I can see, your one aim has been to refute your
opponents when they deny that our souls are the handiwork of God. If
they hold such a view, you are right in thinking that it should be
condemned. Were they to say the same thing of our bodies, they would be
forced to retract it, or else be held up to execration. For what
Christian can deny that every single human body is the work of God? Yet
when we admit that they are of divine origin we do not mean to deny
that they are humanly engendered. When therefore it is asserted that
our souls are procreated from a kind of immaterial seed, and that they,
like our bodies, come to us from our parents, yet are made souls by the
working of God, it is not by human guesses that the assertion is to be
refuted, but by the witness of divine scripture. Numbers of passages
may indeed be quoted from the sacred books which have canonical
authority, to prove that our souls are God’s handiwork. But such
passages only refute those who deny that each several human soul is
made by God; not at all those who while they admit this contend that,
like our bodies, they are formed by divine agency through the
instrumentality of parents. To refute these you must look for
unmistakable texts; or, if you have already discovered such, shew your
affection by communicating them to me. For though I seek them most
diligently I fail to find them.