23. The Arians who were excommunicated for their
impiety by Alexander, the late Bishop of Alexandria, of blessed memory,
were not only proscribed by the brethren in the several cities, but
were also anathematised by the whole body assembled together in the
great Council of Nicæa. For theirs was no ordinary offence,
neither had they sinned against man, but against our Lord Jesus Christ
Himself, the Son of the living God. And yet these persons who were
proscribed by the whole world, and branded in every Church, are said
now to have been admitted to communion again; which I think even you
ought to hear with indignation. Who then are the parties who dishonour
a council? Are not they who have set at nought the votes of the Three
hundred The
number of the Fathers at the Nicene Council is generally considered to
have been 318, the number of Abraham’s servants, Gen. xiv.
14.
Anastasius (Hodeg. 3. fin.) referring to the first three
Ecumenical Councils, speaks of the faith of the 318, the 150, and the
200. [Prolegg. ch. ii. §3 (1).], and have preferred impiety to godliness? The
heresy of the Arian madmen was condemned and proscribed by the whole
body of Bishops everywhere; but the Bishops Athanasius and Marcellus
have many supporters who speak and write in their behalf. We have
received testimony in favour of Marcellus Cf.
§32., that
he resisted the advocates of the Arian doctrines in the Council of
Nicæa; and in favour of Athanasius Cf.
§73., that
at Tyre nothing was brought home to him, and that in the Mareotis,
where the Reports against him are said to have been drawn up, he was
not present. Now you know, dearly beloved, that ex parte
proceedings are of no weight, but bear a suspicious appearance.
Nevertheless, these things being so, we, in order to be accurate, and
neither shewing any prepossession in favour of yourselves, nor of those
who wrote in behalf of the other party, invited those who had written
to us to come hither; that, since there were many who wrote in their
behalf, all things might be enquired into in a council, and neither the
guiltless might be condemned, nor the person on his trial be accounted
innocent. We then are not the parties who dishonour a council, but they
who at once and recklessly have received the Arians whom all had
condemned, and contrary to the decision of the judges. The greater part
of those judges have now departed, and are with Christ; but some of
them are still in this life of trial, and are indignant at learning that certain persons
have set aside their judgment.