Eusebius looked upon the Pastoral Epistles as undoubtedly genuine,
and placed them among the Homologumena, or undisputed writings
(compare Bk. III. chaps. 3 and 25). The external testimony for them is
very strong, but their genuineness has, during the present century,
been quite widely denied upon internal grounds. The advanced critical
scholars of Germany treat their non-Pauline authorship as completely
established, and many otherwise conservative scholars follow their
lead. It is impossible here to give the various arguments for or
against their genuineness; we may refer the reader particularly to
Holtzmann’s Die Pastoralbriefe, kritisch und exegetisch
behandelt (1880), and to his Einleitung (1886), for the most
complete presentation of the case against the genuineness; and to
Weiss’ Einleitung in das N. T. (1886), p. 286 sqq., and to
his Commentary on the Pastoral Epistles, in the fifth edition of the
Meyer Series, for a defense of their genuineness, and also to
Woodruff’s article in the Andover Review, October, 1886,
for a brief and somewhat popular discussion of the subject. The second
epistle must have been written latest of all Paul’s epistles,
just before his death,—at the termination of his second
captivity, or of his first, if his second be denied.