612Chapter IX. Various quibbling arguments, advanced by the Arians to show
that the Son had a beginning of existence, are considered and refuted, on the
ground that whilst the Arians plainly prove nothing, or if they prove anything,
prove it against themselves, (inasmuch as He Who is the beginning of all
cannot Himself have a beginning), their reasonings do not even hold true
with regard to facts of human existence. Time could not be before He was,
Who is the Author of time--if indeed at some time He was not in existence,
then the Father was without His Power and Wisdom. Again, our own human
experience shows that a person is said to exist before he is born.
618Chapter X. The objection that Christ, on the showing of St. John, lives because
of the Father, and therefore is not to be regarded as equal with the Father, is
met by the reply that for the Life of the Son, in respect of His Godhead, there
has never been a time when it began; and that it is dependent upon none,
whilst the passage in question must be understood as referring to His human
life, as is shown by His speaking there of His body and blood. Two expositions
of the passage are given, the one of which is shown to refer to Christ's
Manhood, whilst the second teaches His equality with the Father, as also His
likeness with men. Rebuke is administered to the Arians for the insult which
they are seeking to inflict upon the Son, and the sense in which the Son can
be said to live “because of” the Father is explained, as also the union of life
with the divine Life. A further objection, based upon the Son's prayer that He
may be glorified by the Father, is briefly refuted.
623Chapter XI. The particular distinction which the Arians endeavoured to prove
upon the Apostle's teaching that all things are “of” the Father and “through”
the Son, is overthrown, it being shown that in the passage cited the same
Omnipotence is ascribed both to Father and to Son, as is proved from various
texts, especially from the words of St. Paul himself, in which heretics foolishly
find a reference to the Father only, though indeed there is no diminution or
inferiority of the Son's sovereignty proved, even by such a reference. Finally,
the three phrases, “of Whom,” “through Whom,” “in Whom,” are shown to
suppose or imply no difference (of power), and each and all to hold true of
the Three Persons.
628Chapter XII. The comparison, found in the Gospel of St. John, of the Son to
a Vine and the Father to a husbandman, must be understood with reference
to the Incarnation. To understand it with reference to the Divine Generation
is to doubly insult the Son, making Him inferior to St. Paul, and bringing Him
down to the level of the rest of mankind, as well as in like manner the Father
also, by making Him not merely to be on one footing with the same Apostle,
but even of no account at all. The Son, indeed, in so far as being God, is also
xxix