CHURCHMEN AND STATESMEN
the situation was too tense for such mild counsels, and Argyll
certainly was not the man to alter circumstances by sheer force
of personality. Too loyal to the covenant to follow an Episco-
palian monarch, he was yet unwilling to accept the system of
the commonwealth, and thus was led to take a part in the
ghastly farce which made Charles II. a " covenanted " king.
That hypocritical shadow was swept away by the reality of
Cromwell's sword, but Argyll never recovered his former
influence. Historically his character is hard to estimate ; he
may have been ambitious, he certainly did things which
were both cruel and mean, but he lost his life in the service
of his country, and failed because his ideal was too high.
Limited monarchy and a strong national religion, or a system
of toleration, are not necessarily incompatibles, but they could
not coexist when the King was Charles II. and the religion
Presbyterianism.
In the crowd of the " new forcers of conscience," however,
there stands out pre-eminent one who strove for toleration and
who loved his King, but whose premature death saved him from
the impasse which confronted Argyll. Alexander Henderson
was essentially the statesman of the covenant as Johnston
was its framer. It was he who saw that the differences of the
Presbyterians laid Scotland open to the tamperings of Traquair
and Roxburghe ; and the National Covenant, worded in a way
which satisfied all branches, was his effective answer to these
schemes. Henderson was the moderator who at Glasgow put
the momentous question whether, despite the Commissioner's
withdrawal, the Assembly was still the Assembly, and who in the
name of Presbyterianism cast down the gauntlet to the King.
Twice in the years of strife which followed was he supreme in
the counsels of the Church. The Catechisms, the Confession of
Faith, the Directory, all owe much to Alexander Henderson, and
yet he loved his King ; so well, indeed, that he was at one time
85