6. Another design is to dignify monasticism as the true
ethical ideal and goal of Christianity,—as the philosophy which
is to supplant all the ancient intellectual strivings of
reason,—and he announces this purpose as follows: “Nor is
it foreign to ecclesiastical history to introduce in this work an
account of those who were the fathers and originators of what is
denominated monachism, and of their immediate successors, whose
celebrity is well known to us either by observation or report. For I
would neither be considered ungracious towards them, nor willing to
consign their virtue to oblivion, nor yet be thought ignorant of their
history; but would wish to leave behind me such a record of their
manner of life that others, led by their example, might attain to a
blessed and happy end” (i. 1). He is here quietly resisting a
school of Christians and politicians who were opposed to the absorbing
and destructive qualities of this manner of life; Athanasius, Basil the
Great, Jerome, Chrysostom, had to write in its defense for the same
reason, and he sided with these supporters of its virtues, very
naturally. He is a full believer in the Divine philosophy which
nurtured him; monasticism with its practical strivings after conformity
to the Divine-human Pattern, and its attempt to enthrone the spiritual
over the material has a zealous defender in him, of all its rapt and
grotesque forms. He determined therefore to make it a unique portion of
his history. The discussion of its aims in i. 12 will give us a clue to
his own desire to represent it as almost the resultant force in the
progress of the Divine kingdom; one reads the historian’s
responsive feeling between the lines. This philosophy was the most
useful thing received by man from God; it was superior to all other
knowledge, and warranted the neglect of all worldly science; it strove
to eliminate the adiaphora from ethics,
and to make everything have a moral complexion; one must be doing good,
or else he is doing evil. Its great duties are the discipline of self,
the worship of the Creator, and the cultivation of a spirit of
other-worldness. These canons and goals are the life of the system. It
is the philosophy which is to take the place of the old theoretical
schemes; and it is the great school to fill up the gap made by the
decay of the Hellenic universities. The Christian university founded by
Theodosius in Sozomen’s day, was indeed a blow to this
educational ideal. While we may have no accord with his view of this
ethical phenomenon, we must concede him the merit of discerning its
significance and intent, and allow that he was wise to give us so full
an account of its elaboration, and so much detail and scrap of
biography; for it was a dominant element in the history of this time.
It formed men and measures. The reproach of Sozomen on this score is
wholly a mistake; he has done us capital service in not neglecting this
element, otherwise we could have but little conception of its
historical setting, of its patience, its tireless devotion, and we
would have to resort to Palladius or Rufinus and the individual
biographies. Moreover, it is an uncritical spirit which recoils from
dissecting the awful and often repulsive details of legalistic
self-denial. After discoursing on the local origin of monasticism and
the forms it assumed, we have chapters containing brief sketches of
hermits, laurists, and cœnobites (i. 12, 13, 14, iii. 14). The
people looked to the monks for the color of their theology (iv. 10).
Arianism felt its weakness without them and ineffectually sought their
suppression (vi. 20). The Nicene faith uniformly received the support
of these communities (vi. 27), to which they remained devoted under all
persecutions. Another series of biographies follows in vi. 28–34:
Theophilus (viii. 12) has a preliminary struggle with them to carry
forward his plots against John. The royal court itself under
Pulcheria’s leadership reflected its severe discipline (ix. 13).
Sozomen seems also to have studied the rules of various bodies, some of
whose details he gives, and indulges in a sort of comparative study of
their regulations (vi. 30). Yet with all his implied admiration of the
heroes of this system, who went to the almost extreme of abstinence, he
remarks in reviewing the discipline
of Theotimus (vii. 26): “I consider it to be the part of the
philosopher to yield to the demand of these appetites from necessity,
and not from the love of sensual gratification.” It is to be
noted that he omits for the most part the immoral forms of monasticism,
such as Evagrius gives us a highly rhetorical account of.