ST. ANDREWS UNIVERSITY
and Church law have flourished most, and many divinity professors
have proved themselves good leaders in University business and
in the Church courts, but the theological output may perhaps
be thought meagre. This state of matters has not been confined
to St. Andrews ; it has been the case with Scotland generally ;
and the reasons may be given for it. Scottish religion has
been too controversial to develop theology—this was spoken
of above. The union with England has had the effect of
isolating Scotland from the Continent and Scottish theology
from the Continental schools, from which fresh life was formerly
drawn, while many young Scotsmen of ability have been drawn
to the English rather than the Scottish Church. The theology
of Scotland stood still in the eighteenth century, as did that of
other countries. The one considerable teacher of St. Mary's
College at this period was Dr. George Hill (Principal of
St. Mary's, 1791-1820), the leader of the Moderate party,
whose Lectures on Divinity was the text-book on the subject
of doctrine in the Scottish divinity halls up to a time not long
past, and set forth a moderate Calvinism in a graceful and
persuasive style.
In the first half of the nineteenth century the dominant
religious thought in Scotland was narrow and unprogressive in
a marked degree. Men of spiritual character who showed any
originality in their writings were deposed for no real heresy,
the freer theology of Germany was held up to reprobation
by men of small qualifications as critics but of unbounded
assurance as champions of orthodoxy, and strict adherence to
the traditional system was regarded and enforced as the first
duty of the Church.
But a great change was at hand. The dawn of a more
reasonable theology was connected at St. Andrews with the
appointment ofJohn Tulloch as Principal of St. Mary's College
in the year 1854. Quite a young man—he was in his thirty-
120