in the one name as compared with the other, neither, surely, will the things signified by the
names be mutually different in nature.
And now that I have exposed this futile and pointless sham-argument, it seems to me
that I may well pass by without discussion what he next puts together by way of attack upon
our master’s statement. For a sufficient proof of the folly of his remarks is to be found in
his actual argument, which of itself proclaims aloud its feebleness. To be entangled in a
contest with such things as this is like trampling on the slain. For when he sets forth with
much confidence some passage from our master, and treats it with preliminary slander and
contempt, and promises that he will show it to be worth nothing at all, he meets with the
same fortune as befalls small children, to whom their imperfect and immature intelligence,
and the untrained condition of their perceptive faculties, do not give an accurate understand-
ing of what they see. Thus they often imagine that the stars are but a little way above their
heads, and pelt them with clods when they appear, in their childish folly; and then, when
the clod falls, they clap their hands and laugh and brag to their comrades as if their throw
had reached the stars themselves. Such is the man who casts at the truth with his childish
missile, who sets forth like the stars those splendid sayings of our master, and then hurls
from the ground,—from his downtrodden and grovelling understanding,—his earthy and
unstable arguments. And these, when they have gone so high that they have no place to fall
from, turn back again of themselves by their own weight828. Now the passage of the great
Basil is worded as follows829:—
“Yet what sane man would agree with the statement that of those things of which the
names are different the essences must needs be divergent also? For the appellations of Peter
and Paul, and, generally speaking, of men, are different, while the essence of all is one:
wherefore, in most respects we are mutually identical, and differ one from another only in
those special properties which are observed in individuals: and hence also appellations are
not indicative of essence, but of the properties which mark the particular individual. Thus,
when we hear of Peter, we do not by the name understand the essence (and by ‘essence’ I
here mean the material substratum), but we are impressed with the conception of the
properties which we contemplate in him.” These are the great man’s words. And what skill
he who disputes this statement displays against us, we learn,—any one, that is, who has
leisure for wasting time on unprofitable matters,—from the actual composition of Eunomius.
From his writings, I say, for I do not like to insert in my own work the nauseous stuff
our rhetorician utters, or to display his ignorance and folly to contempt in the midst of my
own arguments. He goes on with a sort of eulogy upon the class of significant words which
828 Altering Oehler’s punctuation slightly.
829 S. Basil adv. Eunomium II. 4 (p. 240 C.). The quotation as here given is not in exact verbal agreement
with the Benedictine text.
371
The seventh book shows from various statements made to the Corinthians and…