The mistake into which Gregory I. fell in ascribing to
Sozomen the commendation of Theodore of Mopsuestia, with which
Theodoret really closes his history, led Baronius to maintain that we
did not have the whole of Sozomen; and others have asserted the same
for reasons which are indeed sufficient to prove that the history is
unfinished, but not that anything is lost. That we have all that
Sozomen wrote is more likely, because the Tripartite History at x. 24
makes the last use of Sozomen at viii. 25; it would surely have gone
further in its dependence upon him had the later controversy been
treated of, since he had been already a chief authority. Nicephorus
Callistus, Historia Ecclesiastica, xiv. 8, gives the account of
the finding of Zechariah in c. 9; the story of Stephen in c. 10; then
the story of the forty martyrs. His source beyond is Socrates, until
Evagrius takes up the thread of affairs. If Sozomen had written the
more recent events parallel with Socrates, Nicephorus would undoubtedly
have followed him as before. Of Theophanes, one cannot speak so
confidently. Moreover, we cannot help asking, since we have Socrates,
Theodoret, and Evagrius complete, why should Sozomen, who was so
admired an author, have suffered any loss? Now, if we have Sozomen
entire so far as he wrote, why did he stop where he did? There are no
sufficient subjective reasons to be offered. It could scarcely have
been in any unfavorable criticism of his prince, for the work seems to
have been accepted by his imperial patron; and there was certainly
nothing as objectionable in Sozomen, as in Socrates or in Olympiodorus.
Nor is it likely that the unhappiness which invaded the court, the
domestic jealousies, which rent its religious as well as connubial
peace, or the quarrels over Cyrus or Paulinus or Chrysaphius, in any
way restrained him; for he was beyond some, if not all of these
agitations, at the time of his writing, and he had deliberately chosen
to ignore such noble personages as Anthemius, Troïlus, Synesius,
Aurelianus, and Eudocia, so that we can argue little from his silence,
save his manifest jealousy for Pulcheria, and his hostility to certain
more liberal tendencies developed under Eudocia. The Nestorian
controversy would have been a choice field wherein to exalt the
influence of Pulcheria, as he himself suggested. On the whole, one is
constrained to believe that Sozomen died before he had completed the
record which he had proposed to himself. He must have been nearing his
seventieth year when thus suddenly arrested in his chosen study.