“Not to speak of many, let the prophetess herself tell us of Alexander,1629 who called
himself a martyr, with whom she is in the habit of banqueting, and who is worshiped1630
by many. We need not mention his robberies and other daring deeds for which he was
punished, but the archives1631 contain them.
7. Which of these forgives the sins of the other? Does the prophet the robberies of the
martyr, or the martyr the covetousness of the prophet? For although the Lord said, ‘Provide
neither gold, nor silver, neither two coats,’1632 these men, in complete opposition, transgress
in respect to the possession of the forbidden things. For we will show that those whom they
call prophets and martyrs gather their gain not only from rich men, but also from the poor,
and orphans, and widows.
8. But if they are confident, let them stand up and discuss these matters, that if convicted
they may hereafter cease transgressing. For the fruits of the prophet must be tried; ‘for the
tree is known by its fruit.’1633
9. But that those who wish may know concerning Alexander, he was tried by Æmilius
Frontinus,1634 proconsul at Ephesus; not on account of the Name,1635 but for the robberies
which he had committed, being already an apostate.1636 Afterwards, having falsely declared
1629 This fragment gives us our only information in regard to this Alexander. That there may be some truth
in the story told by Apollonius cannot be denied. It is possible that Alexander was a bad man, and that the
Montanists had been deceived in him, as often happens in all religious bodies. Such a thing might much more
easily happen after the sect had been for a number of years in a flourishing condition than in its earlier years;
and the exactness of the account, and the challenge to disprove it, would seem to lend it some weight. At the
same time Apollonius is clearly as unprincipled and dishonest a writer as the anonymous, and hence little reliance
can be placed upon any of his reports to the discredit of the Montanists. If the anonymous made so many accus-
ations out of whole cloth, Apollonius may have done the same in the present instance; and the fact that many
still “worshiped” him would seem to show that Apollonius’ accusations, if they possessed any foundation, were
at any rate not proven.
1630 A very common accusation brought against various sects. Upon the significance of it, see Harnack,
Dogmengeschichte, I. p. 82, note 2.
1631 ὀπισθόδομος, originally the back chamber of the old temple of Athenæ on the Acropolis at Athens,
where the public treasure was kept. It then came to be used of the inner chamber of any temple where the public
treasure was kept, and in the present instance is used of the apartment which contained the public records or
archives. Just below, Apollonius uses the phrase δημόσιον ἀρχεῖον, in referring to the same thing.
1632 Matt. x. 9, 10.
1633 Matt. xii. 33.
1634 We know, unfortunately, nothing about this proconsul, and hence have no means of fixing the date of
this occurrence.
1635 i.e. of Christ.
1636 παραβ€της
560
The Manner in which Apollonius refuted the Phrygians, and the Persons whom…