SECT. XVII.
Containing some further observations on what is said by Mr. W. in support of the 13th
objection, concerning God’s commanding all the members of the visible church, that are not
ignorant nor scandalous, to attend all external covenant duties.
It has been already demonstrated (sect. 8th of this third part) that in this argument the
question is begged, notwithstanding what Mr. W. has said to the contrary, which sufficiently
overthrows the whole argument. Nevertheless, that I may pass by nothing, which those who
are on Mr. W.‘s side may be likely to think material, I will here make some further observa-
tions on this objection, as represented and supported by Mr. W.
The chief thing, that has the plausible appearance of argument in what Mr. S. and Mr.
W. say on this head, is this; “That for God to require all who are in covenant to come to the
Lord’s supper, and yet to forbid them to come unconverted, is to suppose, that he both
commands them and forbids them at the same time.” And this is thought to be the more
manifest, inasmuch as conversion is not in men’s power. Though it is not denied, but that
God justly requires men to be converted, or to be truly holy. (See p. 129, 130.)
To this I would say,
(1.) If when they speak of commanding and forbidding at the same time, they mean
God’s commanding and forbidding the same thing at the same time, no such consequence
follows from my principles. For that thing, and that only, which I suppose God requires of
any, is to come to the Lord’s supper with a sanctified heart; and that this God requires at all
times, and never forbids at any time; and that to come without this qualification, is what he
always forbids, and requires at no time. So that what he requires, at the same time he forbids
something, is not the same thing that he forbids; but a very different and contrary one. And
it is no absurdity, to suppose, that God requires one thing, and forbids a contrary thing at
the same time.
To illustrate this by an example: It was the duty of the Jews at Jerusalem, openly to confess
christ, to own him as the Messiah, at that hour when he was led away to be crucified, and
openly to testify their adoring respect to him on that extraordinary occasion. But yet they
did not believe him to be the Messiah, and could not believe it, (many of them at least,) since
they looked on his present abject circumstances as a demonstration, that he was not the
Messiah. It was beyond their power, at least at once, in that instant, to give their assent, with
528
all their hearts, to such a supposition. Nor was it in their power, to exercise an adoring respect
to him: for, besides their strong prejudices, most of them were judicially hardened, and
given up to a spirit of unbelief and obstinate rejection of him; as appears by that account,
(John xii. 39, 40.) “Therefore they could not believe, because that Esaias said again, He hath
blinded their eyes, and hardened their heart, that they should not see with their eyes,” &c.
(See also Luke xix. 41, 42. and Matt. xiii. 14, 15.) And yet it would have been unlawful for
them to have made a lying profession; to profess, that they believed him to be the Messiah,
SECTION XVII. Of commanding to partake.
2025
SECTION XVII. Of commanding to partake.