Historical Introduction to St. Cyril’s Anathematisms.
There has been some difference of opinion among the learned as to whether St. Cyril’s
Synodal letter which has at its end the anathemas against Nestorius, which hereafter follow,
was formally approved at the Council of Ephesus. The matter is one only of archeological
and historical interest, for from a theological point of view the question is entirely uninter-
esting, since there is no possible doubt that the synod endorsed St. Cyril’s teaching and for
that express reason proceeded at their first session to excommunicate Nestorius. Further
there is no one that disputes that the anathematisms were received at the next General
Council. i.e., of Chalcedon, only twenty years later, and that Theodoret was condemned by
200
the Fifth Ecumenical Council because he wrote against these very Anathemas. This being
the case, to those who value the decrees of Ecumenical Councils because of their ecumenical
character, it is quite immaterial whether these anathematisms were received and approved
by the third Council or no, provided, which is indisputably the case, they have been approved
by some one council of ecumenical authority, so as to become thereby part and parcel of
the ecumenical faith of the Church.
But the historical question is one of some interest, and I shall very briefly consider it.
We have indeed the “Acta” of this council, but I cannot but agree with the very learned Jesuit
Petavius and the Gallican Tillemont in thinking them in a very unsatisfactory condition. I
am fully aware of the temerity of making such a suggestion, but I cannot help feeling that
in the remarks of the Roman representatives, especially in those of the presbyter-legate,
there is some anachronism. Be this as it may, it is a fact that the Acts do not recite that this
letter of Cyril’s was read, nor do they state that the Anathemas were received. I would suggest,
however, that for those who defend John of Antioch, and criticise the action of St. Cyril, it
is the height of inconsistency to deny that the Council adopted the Anathemas. If it was
the bitterly partisan assembly that they would have us believe, absolutely under the control
of Cyril, there is nothing that, ὰ priori, they would have been more sure to do than adopt
the Anathemas which were universally looked upon as the very fulcrum on which the whole
matter turned.
Bishop Hefele was at first of opinion that the letter was merely read, being led to this
conclusion by the silence of the Acts with regard to any acceptance of it, and indeed at first
wrote on that side, but he afterwards saw grounds to change his mind and expresses them
with his usual clearness, in the following words:
(Hefele, Hist. of Councils. Vol. III., p. 48, note 2.)
We were formerly of opinion that these anathematisms were read at Ephesus, but not
expressly confirmed, as there is hardly anything on the subject in the Acts. But in the Fifth
Ecumenical Council (collatio vj.) it is said: “The holy Council at Chalcedon approved this
teaching of Cyril of blessed memory, and received his Synodical letters, to one of which are
appended the xij. anathemas” (Mansi, t. ix., p. 341; Hardouin, t. iij., p. 167). If, however,
Historical Introduction to St. Cyril's Anathematisms.
383
Historical Introduction to St. Cyril's Anathematisms.